Yogurt was a favorite food of mine. It was perfect for breakfast, lunch, or just a snack. When I became vegan, I tried dairy-free yogurt and it was horrible. I thought yogurt was a thing of the past for me. That made me sad because yogurt is a healthy cultured food that offers lots of probiotics.

Luckily, dairy-free yogurt has come a long way and there are a few brands out there that are really good. Read How to Choose the Best Dairy-Free Yogurt for tips on picking the best ones for you and avoiding those with added sugars and fillers. Another option is to make your own dairy-free yogurt. Trust me, it’s not as complicated as it sounds. It’s actually very easy and you get to choose the ingredients, flavors, and add-ins.

Here’s how to make your own dairy-free yogurt at home.

1. Choose the Non-Dairy Milk

Coconut milk

Source: Coconut Milk

Yogurt can be made with any non-dairy milk. Soy, cashew, and coconut are most popular because they are thick and have natural fats. Choose whichever milk is your favorite or use our guide: Which Milk for What Recipe: A Non-Dairy Milk Guide for All Your Cooking and Baking Needs. You can keep the yogurt raw by preparing it in a blender or you can make it in a saucepan over low heat.

2. Add a Thickener

Raw Coconut Dairy-Free Yogurt

Source: Raw Coconut Yogurt

To make the yogurt thick enough to eat with a spoon, you can add a thickening agent. Agar agar and tapioca starch are both good choices as they are readily available and easy to use. Some people choose not to use a thickener. If you’re making coconut yogurt, you can add coconut meat to thicken the mixture as in this Homemade Coconut Yogurt and this Raw Coconut Yogurt. Another option is to use the coconut cream that rises to the top of a chilled can of coconut milk. A third way to make the yogurt thick is to strain it through a cheesecloth overnight.

3. Add Cultures

Vegan Homemade Probiotic Cashew Yogurt

Source: Homemade Probiotic Cashew Yogurt

One of the best things about yogurt is how healthy it is because it’s filled with probiotics. You can add probiotic powder or liquid to your homemade yogurt. Make sure the probiotics you buy are vegan and gluten-free, if necessary. Check out What to Look For in a Probiotic for shopping tips. If you take probiotics in capsule form, you can simply empty a couple of capsules into your mixture as in this Homemade Probiotic Cashew Yogurt.

4. Add Flavors

Cinnamon Coconut Yogurt

Source: Cinnamon Coconut Yogurt

You can add flavors to your yogurt to get some variety. Make vanilla yogurt by adding a little vanilla bean powder, add some warm cinnamon, or make chocolate-flavored yogurt with a bit of cacao. If you want your yogurt sweeter, add maple syrup, stevia, or whatever type of sweetener you like to use. Try this delicious Cinnamon Coconut Yogurt and this Banana Buckwheat Yogurt.

4. Fermentation and Chilling

Coconut Yogurt Tzatziki

Source: Coconut Yogurt Tzatziki

Now the yogurt needs to ferment. Transfer the yogurt into a bowl and cover it. Allow it to sit in a warm, dark place for up to 48 hours. It should start to taste tart after 24 hours. How tart you want it is up to you. After 48 hours, the yogurt will taste sour. The yogurt can also ferment in a dehydrator for several hours at about 100 degrees. For detailed instructions, see How to Make Coconut Yogurt in a Dehydrator. When the yogurt is done fermenting, transfer it to the fridge and keep chilled until you’re ready to eat it.

5. Enjoy Your Yogurt

Banana Buckwheat Yogurt

Source: Banana Buckwheat Yogurt

Now that your yogurt is ready to eat, it’s time to get creative. Add in bananas, nuts, berries, granola, cacao nibs or whatever you like. Use your yogurt to make Coconut Yogurt Tzatziki for your falafel salad. Turn your homemade yogurt into this delicious Frozen Berry Yogurt Bark and Lemon Lavender Yogurt Cake.  Enjoy it in this Papaya and Coconut Yogurt Breakfast and this Cherry Chocolate Stovetop Granola with Toasted Cashew Banana Yogurt.

It’s amazing how easy it is to make your own yogurt. There’s nothing like getting to choose and control the ingredients in your food. Have fun playing with all the different types and flavors of yogurt you can make!

We also highly recommend downloading our Food Monster App, which is available for iPhone, and can also be found on Instagram and Facebook. The app has more than 15,000 plant-based, allergy-friendly recipes, and subscribers gain access to new recipes every day. Check it out! For more Vegan Food, Health, Recipe, Animal, and Life content published daily, don’t forget to subscribe to the One Green Planet Newsletter! Being publicly funded gives us a greater chance to continue providing you with high-quality content. Please support us!