Welcome Green Monsters! We're your online guide to making conscious choices that help people, animals and the planet.
Download food monster: the biggest, baddest, yummiest vegan food app!
single

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR Newsletter

While some meat-eaters may not want to admit it (or hear about it), it is largely understood that the process that brings beef to our supermarkets involves harming cowsThere are plenty of people who are not vegetarian who understand why someone might not want to eat cows: after all, they are sentient beings who deserve a happy life as much as we do. 

Many of us, however, continue to consume dairy believing that the cows aren’t killed for milk or cheese, so it must be okay. I myself once believed this myth, thinking that if the animal doesn’t have to die to “give” milk, what could possibly be the issue.

The truth is dairy cows lead horrible lives, filled with grief, pain and suffering.  Not only does the dairy industry fuel the veal industry, but the dairy cow herself is ultimately slaughtered as well. With all this in mind, we have to ask ourselves, “Is there more cruelty in a glass of milk or a pound of beef?”

Is There More Cruelty in a Glass of Milk or Pound of Beef?Jo-Anne McArthur/We Animals

The Life of a “Beef” Cow

 

Birth

Cows raised for beef are separated from their mothers at a young age, though not as soon as dairy cows and veal calves. According the Department of Agriculture, Forestry & Fisheries, “the major priority in beef production is to produce as many calves as possible.”

This means calves are weaned around the age of seven to eight months, which gives the mother cow time to “regain condition after weaning.”

Is There More Cruelty in a Glass of Milk or Pound of Beef?Jo-Anne McArthur/We Animals

Lifespan  

While cows can live up to 25 years, cows raised for beef are generally slaughtered between one and three years of age.

For the first six months of the beef cow’s life, he (or she) spends his time in the pasture. According to the ASPCA, cows are the only factory farmed animal who still spend some time outdoors. After this period of six months (sometimes cows get up to a year), the cow is then moved to a feedlot with hundreds or thousands of other cows. Here their diet changes to one of mostly grain, which can cause digestive issues, pain and even death. The beef steer/cow will stay here until they reach slaughter weight.

Is There More Cruelty in a Glass of Milk or Pound of Beef?Jo-Anne McArthur/We Animals

Babies

With the exception of breeding cows, most cows destined to become beef are not bred, so they are spared the pain of losing their children.

Treatment

There are many common industry practices that factory farms use that would be considered animal abuse if carried out on a domestic animals. Here are a few cows raised for beef are subjected to.

Male calves are castrated at a young age, “to improve meat quality.” Some of the methods used to castrate them include surgically removing testicles with a scalpel, “crushing spermatic cords with a clamp, and constricting blood flow to the scrotum until testicles die and fall off.” Regardless of the method used, pain relief is rarely provided and the steer is in pain for several days.

In addition to castration, cows are subjected to branding. The branding iron is 950 degrees Fahrenheit and pressed against the cows skin for several seconds while he is held to the ground. Painkillers are not provided during this procedure either.

Is There More Cruelty in a Glass of Milk or Pound of Beef?Wikimedia Commons
 

Death

After about one year of life, anywhere up to three years, the cow can be sent to slaughter. The Humane Methods of Slaughter Act requires that livestock be rendered insensible to pain before they are shackled and their throats are slit. “Acceptable” methods for rendering the animal unconscious include “forcefully striking the animal on the forehead with a bolt gun or properly placing electrical shocks.” Sadly, many undercover investigations show that this requirement is often overlooked as many cows are still conscious when killed.

The Life of a Dairy Cow

 

Birth

When a dairy cow is born, she is taken from her mother within 24 hours, if not immediately. The primary reason she does not stay with her mother is so that she does not drink up all the farmer’s profit (e.g. her mother’s milk). That milk is for humans, after all, and if left to her own devices, she’d suck it all down.

Is There More Cruelty in a Glass of Milk or Pound of Beef?Jo-Anne McArthur/ We Animals

Lifespan

Just like beef cows, dairy cows naturally would live about 18 to 22 years, though there are plenty who live well into their twenties. While a beef cow’s life is cut short around four months, a dairy cow’s life ends around five years of age.

Babies 

In order to “give milk,” a dairy cow must be artificially inseminated, because just like humans, she will not produce milk if there isn’t a baby to feed. While many say that cows only need to be pregnant once, the fact remains that in modern factory farming they are inseminated every year in order to keep milk production as high as possible, not to mention the industry also profits from their babies .

Is There More Cruelty in a Glass of Milk or Pound of Beef?Jo-Anne McArthur/We Animals

Treatment

Also like humans, the gestation period of a dairy cow is nine months. She is milked throughout most of her pregnancy and when she gives birth, her baby will be taken from her, just as she was taken from her own mother.If her calf is a boy, he will be chained to a crate for a maximum of 16 weeks before being slaughtered for veal. If her calf is a girl, she will become a dairy cow and the cycle will continue.

After her baby is taken from her, the dairy cow is hooked up to machines for milking. According to the ASPCA, the average “dairy cows each produce about 100 pounds of milk per day — 10 times more than cows living just a few decades ago. This is due to bovine growth hormones, unnatural diets and being bred selectively for massive milk production.”

Is There More Cruelty in a Glass of Milk or Pound of Beef?Jo-Anne McArthur/We Animals
 

Cows are maternal creatures. They will spend hours after their baby is born licking and tending to them, if given the chance. When their babies are pulled, often dragged away from them, they often bellow for days.

One cruel practice that many dairy cow face is having their tail surgically removed without painkillers. It’s believed that doing so keeps the udder clean, but this myth has been disproven.

Cows are also dehorned, a process in which the farmer will cut or burned off the horns. Again, no painkillers are provided.

Death

Many avoid beef because the animal has to be slaughtered, but continue to drink milk because we believe it to be a benign product. It’s true that a dairy cow doesn’t have to be killed to produce milk, but she doesn’t exactly go to a retirement community at the end of her production period. After about five years, a cow’s milk supply begins to dwindle and she is no longer as profitable as her younger peers. So what does a farmer do? He or she slaughters her. Yes, a dairy cow’s life ends in slaughter, just as the beef cow’s does.

Is There More Cruelty in a Glass of Milk or Pound of Beef?Jo-Anne McArthur/We Animals
 

So in the end, the dairy cow is slaughtered too. Given how much longer the dairy cow lives, and that cows raised for beef do not have their babies stolen from them every year: it would seem, in fact, there is more cruelty in a glass of milk. That is not to say the suffering of beef cows is insignificant, we now understand the pain endured in their lives. However, it’s time attention is also paid to the plight of the dairy cow. She too is suffering and we have the power to stop it. All we have to do is put down the glass of milk.

Image source: Mercy for Animals/Flickr



Want to read more posts like this? Sign up for our newsletter below!​

Browse through some recent posts below:

How These 4 Incredible Organizations Are Working to Keep Pets With Their Families and Out of Shelters

How These 4 Incredible Organizations Are Working to Keep Pets With Their Families and Out of Shelters

3 Incredible Organizations Dedicated to Helping Stray Dogs in Native American Communities

3 Incredible Organizations Dedicated to Helping Stray Dogs in Native American Communities

Report Reveals the Horrific Reality of Life in Captivity for Lolita the Orca – Here’s How to Help

Distressing Report Reveals the Sad Reality of Life in Captivity for Lolita the Orca – What You Can Do to Help

Balloon Releases Are Killing Wildlife and Marine Animals – Here’s What You Can Do Instead

The Devastating Effects Balloon Releases Have on Wildlife and Marine Animals and What You Can Do About It

Disclosure: One Green Planet accepts advertising, sponsorship, affiliate links and other forms of compensation, which may or may not influence the advertising content, topics or articles written on this site. Click here for more information.

182 comments on “Is There More Cruelty in a Glass of Milk or Pound of Beef?”

Click to add comment
Nita Pawar Rana
15 Days ago

Both equally cruel!!!! in todays times with rampant industrialisation....and meat a profit making industry with demand for milk everincreasing and nebver enough....we all commit a sin with our demands milk produce and with meat -the inhumane treatment to meat animals


Reply
Sofie Lund Petersen
15 Days ago

Ida Lund Petersen


Reply
Cunningham Michael Steven
15 Days ago

There is no variation of cruelty only the heinousness of the amount of corruption.


Reply
Lynn Bowman
15 Days ago

Neither are cruel. God put these animals on earth for the sole purpose of nurishing humans. Their hides have been used for warmth by native Americans and pioneer's for many years. They are not pets.. They are food for us.


Reply
Joanne Holmes
14 Sep 2016

Are you insane ? You are actually saying that enslaving a sentient being ( feelings , emotions ) and stealing it's babies over and over and all the abuse of modern mass farming isn't cruel . God did mention no suffering so you are letting your God down I'm afraid , mass farming wasn't in the plan .

Lynn Bowman
14 Sep 2016

Oh get over it Joanne Holmes I have a right to my opinion just like you. Everybody isn't suppose to agree all the time. Believe it or not you sound just as insane to me as I do to you.

Lynn Bowman
14 Sep 2016

Mass farming is necessary to feed the masses. Science has proven that plants have feelings and reactions too. You don't seem to understand the concept of natural selection. Go back to playing with your dolls and let that poor kitten out if that cage. Dogs and cats were given to us as companions, not to be caged or chained. That is cruelty my friend.

Joanne Holmes
14 Sep 2016

The kitten was caged due to an operation Lynn that kept him on 4 legs instead of 3 , now he runs free with the rest of the family as do the other sick animals - sorry you got that totally wrong . I work with the cat protection charity to save animals and send them off to a better life . You contradict yourself , you tell me to set an animal free on the one hand , whilst saying you must enslave and confine on the other . Which is it to be Lynn ? Science has also proved that animals are sentiment beings and recently several countries have recognised it too .. Did you know that ? Do you know what sentient means ? It means the ability to feel as a human being does love , fear , pain , loss do you have those abilities yourself ? As for playing with dolls I never did that, I was too busy educating myself and reading . I suggest you do that yourself .

Lynn Bowman
14 Sep 2016

Don't know when to just shut up do you? Your just another crackpot who has to force your own beliefs on other people. Like I said go back and play with your dolls. Your ridiculous .

Stella Wesley
15 Days ago

There's cruelty to all animals we eat. Milk or beef.


Reply
Anne Chuprevich
16 Days ago

Cruelty in both. Does it matter which is more cruel? Animals are suffering for humans and their tastebuds.


Reply
Dusty Corners
16 Days ago

Neither...livestock are well cared for animals on farms and ranches in the U.S. at least...always a few morons out there that don't do the correct things, but most farmers and ranchers are great people producing plant and animals for our use.


Reply
Rita O'Connell
13 Sep 2016

No

Joanne Holmes
14 Sep 2016

Not on the footage I've seen 😢 violent and brutal ..

Dusty Corners
14 Sep 2016

You all need to get out more

Cynthia Lott
16 Days ago

I was vegetarian for almost 17 years and had given up most dairy except...you guessed it...cheese. I could eat whole cheese pizzas with the best of them but around 6 months ago I did what I have been wanting to do for years now...I gave up that last dairy item I so loved. Cheese. And you know what? I DONT MISS IT! With so many dairy cheese alternatives now, I'm a happy camper. :) x


Reply
Izzy Hobbs
16 Days ago

Maria Hobbs


Reply
Sueanne Roselle
16 Days ago

Yes I'm on it - have been told baby steps and will persevere.


Reply


Subscribe to our Newsletter




Follow us on


Do Not Show This Again

×

Submit to OneGreenPlanet


Terms & Conditions ×