Welcome Green Monsters! We're your online guide to making conscious choices that help people, animals and the planet.
Download food monster: the biggest, baddest, yummiest vegan food app!
Buy the #EatForThePlanet book



A Horse of a Different Color: Carriage Horses Are Neither War Horses Nor Work Horses

A Horse of a Different Color: Carriage Horses Are Neither War Horses Nor Work Horses

Horses have always been the innocent victims – whether taken to war without a choice and worked to death; or used in rodeos, horse racing or New York City’s  inhumane horse-drawn carriage industry.

Sad history – In the age before the automobile, horses were notoriously overworked, and many died in the streets.  In NYC, they pulled wagons loaded with people and goods, and they served as the power for the City’s street trolley system.   Between 100,000 and 200,000 horses lived in the city at the turn of the century.  Many were literally worked to death — their carcasses left on the street waiting for the street cleaners.  From an article by Joel A. Tarr in American Heritage Magazine – Urban Pollution – many long years ago  “The average streetcar nag had a life expectancy of barely two years, and it was a common sight to see drivers and teamsters savagely lashing their overburdened animals.  The mistreatment of city horses was a key factor in moving Henry Bergh to found the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals in 1866.”  

Steven Spielberg’s film War Horse gave me new insight into what the term “work horse” and “war horse”   really meant.  During World War I, horses were transported via rail to New York City to be shipped to Europe for use in the war.  They pulled cannons, trucks and ambulances and were literally worked till they dropped in the ravages of war and hand-to-hand combat. Hundreds of thousands of horses did not make it out alive, dying from artillery fire, starvation and disease. With the end of the war, and with increased mechanization in the 20th century, the need for draft horses declined.  Many of these horses were sold to slaughter.

Humans had contributed to the overpopulation of draft horses by over breeding, cross breeding and selective breeding.  Mules are man made – the hybrid offspring of a female horse and a male donkey.   So are hinnies – a combination of a male horse and female donkey.  A 2008 article from Horseman Magazine says “Most draft horses however were really the result of selective breeding. Programs for breeding were primarily set up to produce these large, muscular and powerful horses.”

Watching “War Horse” provided a window into the ways our society has treated horses through the years.  Horses were domesticated by humans who needed their strength to perform a variety of duties that they were unable to do.  And horses, being the docile animals that they are, complied.    They became known as “beasts of burden” as if this and nothing else described what they were.

Our use of horses over the millenia is nothing to be proud of – the devastation of war; the exploitation of animals – but people felt they had no choice.  Real work needed to be done, and powerful horses were available and capable.   Today, we don’t need to use horses to work for us.  We have a choice, and can and must choose not to exploit them.

Where do they go? – Among the most abused work horses today are those who pull carriages with tourists in major urban areas like New York, Chicago, Boston, Philadelphia,  Charleston, Atlanta and Rome.  In New York, these horses are forced to haul tourists through the congested streets of midtown.     When no longer able to do this pulling, they are removed from the business.    Unconfirmed rumors abound concerning their engraved hoof identification numbers being sanded off so they can’t be identified as a NYC carriage horse when they are in the auction kill pen.  Freedom of Information requests from the  Department of Health reveal a very high turnover of carriage horses – between 60 and 70  a year – about 1/3 of the total horses.   Auctions are the likely place to sell them and recoup costs.  When a horse is sold outside the City, as most are, records are not required to be sent to the Department of Health – only eventual notification that the horse is no longer in the system so the driver does not have to pay the license fee. Although the industry has taken advantage of the NYC landscape to ply their trade, the drivers are not accountable for where the horses go, and the City has never seen fit to change that, despite pleas from advocates who believe they deserve a humane retirement.  There is no transparency in this trade although they benefit from it being a cash only business with few meaningful restrictions.

It has long been suspected that many of these horses are “laundered” with the help of some Amish farmers who essentially act as middlemen.  They will take the horse directly to auction so the blame for the horse ending up in the kill pen is not traced back to the carriage operator.  A perfect example of how this played out was with Bobby II Freedom, a former NYC carriage horse jointly rescued by the Coalition to Ban Horse-Drawn Carriages and Equine Advocates in 2010.  Every year more than 100,000 equines are transported from the US across the Mexican and Canadian borders where they are slaughtered for human consumption and shipped to in Europe and Japan.

The horse of a different color – The present day urban carriage horses are not work horses although the drivers like to pretend they are.  That term needs to be reserved for horses who helped their owners survive before the industrial revolution.  Instead, they  are entertainment horses – they are horses of a different color.  They are often decorated with feathered head dresses, some with glittered body paint and painted hoofs.  Undignified –  a tawdry decoration to attract tourists.

A work horse would pull a plough to till the earth so the farmer could plant seeds and feed his family.  A carriage horse pulls unsuspecting tourists around a city to see the sights,  and according to a recent article in the NY Post, they often get ripped off. These tourists don’t know about cruelty and safety issues, and the carriage drivers certainly aren’t informing them.

A typical day – By law, a NYC carriage horse may work a punishing nine hours a day, seven days a week.  Throughout their long shifts, they are confined between the shafts of their carriage wearing heavy equipment, blinders and a metal bit in their mouths.   During the holiday season, the horses are worked to exhaustion.  The current law requires a 15 minute break every two hours, but it is not enforced.   At other times customers are scarce, the horse stands on the hack line, often ignored by her driver whose attention is elsewhere. She is frequently bored, either mentally shutting down and appearing  dispirited,  or repeatedly pawing / pounding her hoof on the pavement.  It is a form of displacement behavior on which the horse eventually becomes stereotyped.  Restricted by the carriage, she has no freedom of movement.  She is not even able to scratch an itch.

Laws not enforced – Although it is against the law in NYC for horses to be left untethered or unattended, it is a common practice.     In 2007, a horse named Smoothie was attached to her empty carriage waiting unattended at Central Park South when she was spooked by a loud noise.  Frantic, she bolted, got her legs tangled in the carriage and ended up crashing into a tree and dying.  Another horse who saw Smoothie bolt also spooked and ran into traffic, crashing into a car.

On October 28, 2011,  an unattended horse spooked on Central Park South near Columbus Circle, bolting into traffic and ending up in the park where he crashed into the wall.  He is reported to no longer be in the business.

Carriage drivers like to characterize themselves as the experts, the “real horsemen”; this is a thinly veiled and polarizing tactic designed to suggest that anyone who wants to see this business come to an end in the large cities lacks knowledge. They take this line of reasoning even further, stating that proponents of a ban “know nothing about horses” and that the carriage horses–all horses, in fact–need a job. This, of course, is a human concept.

Having knowledge of horses does not equate with treating them well or knowing what is best for them.  Michael Vick knew about dogs, and look how he treated them.  When people make money off the back of a horse or any other animal, their first priority is invariably profit. One does not have to know a fetlock from the withers to know that enslaving these horses and shackling them to a carriage for hours on end is inhumane and is all about what the driver wants – not the horse.

Jobs or respect?  As for needing a job – this is just an excuse to keep the horses working in the carriage business.  Our focus is on urban, commercial / tourist carriage businesses in cities like New York – nothing else.   Horses have highly developed social relationships  and need mental and physical stimulation.  They are exceedingly social animals and should have the opportunity to graze in a pasture in the company of other equines  – something that is denied to them as a carriage horse.

New York City needs to move into the 21st century and stop pretending that this is a big tourist draw or that it provides lots of revenue to the city.  It is not and it does not.  Horse-drawn carriages pose a danger for the horses, their passengers, other vehicles and pedestrians.

It’s way past time to end this cruel and inhumane anachronism.  We hope that time will come in the next few years with the passage of the Avella/Rosenthal  bill  to ban horse-drawn Carriages, which is currently in the New York State legislature.

Image Source r0sss/Flickr

Want to read more posts like this? Sign up for our newsletter below!​

Browse through some recent posts below:

Disclosure: One Green Planet accepts advertising, sponsorship, affiliate links and other forms of compensation, which may or may not influence the advertising content, topics or articles written on this site. Click here for more information.

88 comments on “A Horse of a Different Color: Carriage Horses Are Neither War Horses Nor Work Horses”

Click to add comment
bracelet or blanc cartier copie
6 Months Ago

bracelet or blanc cartier copie So this cauldron holding 800 ISIS will probably be dismantled by the cessation of hostilities-- one way or another.

replique bracelet love cartier occasion
7 Months Ago

replique bracelet love cartier occasion Give it a rest bro. There is no scientifically valid evidence that autism is directly attributable to transgenic food, contaminants, or otherwise. None.

bague bulgari b zero1 replique
8 Months Ago

bague bulgari b zero1 replique Great suggestions, Sabrina! Now if I could get buy-in from my co-workers, life would be much easier and more efficient.

5 Years Ago

You can all thank Obama... horses can now be slaughtered in the USA because he didnt feel that H.R. 2966 should be signed. It prevents the slaughter of horses in the US.

6 Years Ago

You guys are a bunch of assholes if you can't see that these horses are in horrible condition. They do not live to serve humans, but since you think they do, damn right you'll defend this carriaging madness. Typical. I live in Philadelphia, and i see those horses being abused nearly everyday. All these people care about is making money off of these overweight scumbag tourists. Not long ago, some horse collapsed due to having too many fat fucks in the carriage. You know what the driver did? Blamed the horse. You "real horsemen" are selfish bastards.

Susan Oakey
6 Years Ago

Thanks to one green planet for posting Ms. Forel's excellent article on the treatment of carriage horses. I was astounded to read some of the comments that have come in from those who support the carriage horse trade. Of course, one must look at the source. Many of those who posted are, no doubt, themselves carriage horse drivers or owners. I lived in New York City and now live in Dallas - and I have to say that Ms. Forel's observations are very similar to mine. The few meager laws that were created to protect carriage horses are seldom, if ever, enforced. From what I have seen, most horses are made to work in abysmal weather conditions, with little thought to their comfort or well-being. Interestingly, the Dallas carriage horse laws consist, in large part, of a list of the crimes that a driver is permitted to commit while still retaining a license. That tells you a lot about the quality of those who work in the carriage horse trade in Dallas. My thanks to Ms. Forel for her work on behalf of the carriage horses - and to all those who speak out against the abuse of animals!

6 Years Ago

I am so glad that Eva said that about defining cruelty. She means the real kind--as defined by law. for example, the legal troubles that have been faced by Lorenzo Ricccobono in Pennsylvania. In NYC, his business interests are with West Side Livery, which has a way of making headlines for all the wrong reasons. http://articles.nydailynews.com/2006-01-04/news/18329121_1_carriage-horse-bizarre-accident

6 Years Ago

Only in America. A woman watches a movie, forms an opinion on something she has no experience with and decides carraiges are cruel and whips up a frenzied storm to ban it. This is like Sarah Palin running on a lower tax platform-when in her half term as Governor , SHE RAISED TAXES. Yet she has hordes of people jump on her bandwagon-not saying the platform is bad, but seriously her? Here you have someone who openly admits she got her opinions watching a movie and she has hordes of followers religiously hanging on to her every word. No wonder our country is so messed up.

Sarah May
6 Years Ago

Horses do not belong in the chaos of a city like NYC or Rome or any other city where they are routinely injured and often killed in accidents with people, cars or just from spooking. While I agree that horses may not be best off left alone in a pasture, I do know that they'd be better off with a shorter life of freedom and dying of natural causes than hauling around fat tourists in the sweltering heat where they have to stand in their own piss for hours at a time with no break, ever, only to be taken to tiny stalls. Horses in NYC and Rome look bored and unhealthy. The drivers in both of these cities often are engaged on their phones, smoking and sometimes do not notice their horses are thirsty. h and BTW there are plenty of equine rights people that know a lot about horses and have lived or live with horses and don't consider them OBJECTS to use at will but rathr members of hte family, like a dog or cat.

Another Anonymous
24 May 2012

Really, How do you KNOW that horses would be "better off" living a short brutal life in the wild than living the life of a well taken care of carriage horse in a city? THAYT is your opinion, not a FACT. You can KNOW that YOU believe that, but your belief doesn't make it so. Sarah, the way some of you carry on about the "chaos io the city" it sounds like you don't think there should BE cities. Thre is a wonderful story on this thread about a horse that was once a show horse and ended up almost going to an auction. Instead the horse was taken in by a carriage driver and now helps her raise money to take care of outher horses at her farm. It didn't sound to me like she thought her horses were "OBJECTS to use at will" as you are claiming carriage drivers do. It sounded to me, from her story, that she thinks of those horses as family members.

Ban Horse-Drawn Carriages
6 Years Ago

Time to ban horse-drawn carriages in NYC. Period. to the person who suggested there are "photo-shopped" posters: i've never seen one. and I live in NYC and am aware of the deaths, accidents, and human injuries through the years. In fact, 2011 wasn't the best year to be a tourist in a horse-drawn carriage in NYC. Who know what will happen in 2012.


Subscribe to our Newsletter

Follow us on

Do Not Show This Again


Submit to OneGreenPlanet

Terms & Conditions ×