Welcome Green Monsters! We're your online guide to making conscious choices that help people, animals and the planet.
Download food monster: the biggest, baddest, yummiest vegan food app!
Buy the #EatForThePlanet book
single

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR Newsletter

  GET FOOD MONSTER AppX

Imagine walking through a trail alongside the golden grasses of an open prairie in the Western United States when all of the sudden you are stopped frozen by the sound of a thunderous noise of hooves approaching from a distance. As you listen closely, you hear whinnying and soon, the herd is within your sight. With their power, grace, and majesty, horses can aesthetically make any landscape appear beautiful.

But horses also have a much greater purpose, as they help to physically maintain and benefit the health of prairie ecosystems. Millions of horses once roamed free in the Wild West. Unfortunately, by the time the first federal wild free-roaming horse protection law was enacted in 1959, the mustang population had already been drastically reduced. This law only prohibited hunting horses with the help of motor vehicles.

While the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) is now the primary authority that manages wild horse populations. However, the BLM favors cattle interests over that of the wild horse which has lead to the steady decline of the wild horse population. Wild horses play a crucial role in keeping the ecosystem of the west balanced.

Managing Horse Populations to Benefit Cattle

In certain locations, natural horse predators, such as wolves, are now scarce and as a result, the BLM is “concerned” with regulating horse populations to avoid competition with land for domestic cattle. To manage the horses, the bureau issues roundups of wild horses to transfer them to a captive lifestyle. Their methods are often considered inhumane. For example, in 2014, the BLM poorly planned a roundup of approximately 800 horses from private and public lands. Ten died in the process, including four foals and the horses all experienced immense stress and discomfort (not to mention they lost one of the most valued ideals of America – freedom). Approximately 270,000 horses have been removed from U.S. land since 1971.

Furthermore, supply has exceeded demand for selling captured horses for an adoption fee of $125 and most horses end up at auction where they can be purchased for any use the buyer the wishes … sadly most of the time this means they are sold to slaughter for meat.

In order to validate their actions, the BLM has claimed that horses are overpopulating, while destroying critical habitat. Where is this evidence? Nobody knows … We do, however, have ecological evidence of how horses benefit their environment.

Horses Versus Cattle: Benefits of Horses for the Environment

While the BLM is concerned with avoiding grazing competition between wild horses and domestic cattle, there seems to be lack of attention toward addressing the impacts cattle are having on the environment. The ratio of cattle to wild horses on public lands is fifty to one. Wild horses are critical architects of the western ecosystem, so rather than wasting tax dollars funding roundups, if the BLM is really concerned with protecting public lands they should instead focus on protecting horses.

To illustrate the benefits of the presence of the wild horse, let’s look at comparison to how horses affect their ecosystem versus cattle.

1. Maintaining Grass 

While cattle do not have upper teeth and use their tongues to wrap around grass to pull it from the roots, horses only graze the tops of grass blades, allowing grasses to regrow in a healthier state.

2. Improving Soil Quality

Unlike cattle, horses are not ruminants and therefore, do not have four sections of their stomach. This means that their waste contains more nutrients. When horses defecate, they give back to the land through enhancing soil quality. Cattle operations often cause water pollution due to waste containing hormones, antibiotics, heavy metals, ammonia, and pathogens. Many animals depend on horse manure to help maintain soil moisture to prevent brush fires.

3. Use of Water Resources

While cattle enjoy chilling out by water sources, horses are respectful of their ecosystem. Instead of causing erosion and scaring away species diversity (like cattle do), horses tend to drink and move on, leaving minimal impact on stream habitats.

4. Grazing Habits

Since horses are travelers and cattle prefer to just hang out, horses do not exhaust grazing areas like cattle do. Horses are also picky about what they eat and avoid consuming pretty flowers, allowing wild flowers to survive. If a horse consumes seeds, they can still germinate after being passed and thus, horses act as important sources of dispersal for plant species.

5. Lending a Hand to Other Species

In cold climates, many animals will follow the path of horses in order to find access to food and water. The powerful hooves of a horse have the ability to break through ice, making streams once again potable for other animals. Furthermore, horses can make their way to grasses through deep snow, allowing other animals to also graze where horses have been.

Grazing cattle, on the other hand, pose a threat to 14 percent of endangered animal species and 33 percent of plant species as they encroach further into their territory.

Stop Roundups to Save Horses

Cattle are given priority over land because ranchers pay a tax to the BLM for every head of cattle they graze on public lands. The myth that the wild horse poses too much competition to cattle is a simple lie used to justify their systematic removal. It would not be far off to say that cows have become an invasive species in the West, leading to the downfall of keystone species who help to keep the native ecosystem healthy.

There are many organizations working to raise awareness about wild horse roundups. To learn more about how you can help, check out the work of American Wild Horse Preservation.

 

Image source: Bureau of Land Management

Want to read more posts like this? Sign up for our newsletter below!​

Browse through some recent posts below:

10 Shocking Facts About the Lives of Dogs Used In the Testing Industry

10 Shocking Facts About the Lives of Dogs Used In the Testing Industry

So You Have to Give Your Cat a Bath … Here’s How to Do It

It’s Baby Season For Wildlife – Heres What to Do If You Spot an Animal In Need

It's Baby Season For Wildlife – Heres What to Do If You Spot an Animal In Need

5 Ways Factory Farming Is Killing the Environment

5 Ways Factory Farming is Killing the Environment

Disclosure: One Green Planet accepts advertising, sponsorship, affiliate links and other forms of compensation, which may or may not influence the advertising content, topics or articles written on this site. Click here for more information.

20 comments on “Is the Government Destroying the American West Ecosystem by Favoring Cattle Over Wild Horses?”

Click to add comment
Sai Vidhya
10 Days ago

Effective love spell to get lost lover back/stop divorce/save broken marriage [email protected] is the best on urgent love spell casting with 100% result guarantee
Am Sai Vidhya from CA Usa my boyfriend cheated on me and asked for breakup. I don\'t believe at first i try to get back with him but all he told me was he’s with someone else. that he is no longer interested in marrying me at that point i was heart broken coz i love my boyfriend so much that i could not let go off him all of a sudden he left me, i really love him and never can imagine my life without him. not until i came across a powerful real spell caster Dr happy who promise me 48hours urgent love spell to get back with my boyfriend, good forty-eight {48} hours. hmm-mm, it was a good night time at 10:05pm within the days that Dr happy told me that my boyfriend will be back, at first i heard the bell rings getting close to my door i heard someone saying honey!!!, it sound familiar i opened the door and i saw my boyfriend standing and weeping in front of me. i was not surprised because its all i have been praying for him to come back home. Guess what in six days after i noticed my system and my body temperature is changed and i went to clinic for check up and the doctor told me that there is life in me which means i am pregnant i really wants to use this opportunity to thanks Dr happy so much and my lovely collage who directed me to Dr happy if you have any problem or predicament that is worse or exactly like this you have been into, i plead you to contact Dr happy on [email protected] you can also view on his blogs site... https://happylovespell2.blogspot.com.ng/ whatsapp/call...+2348133873774


Reply
CassieTiffany
11 Days ago

Save your marriage with urgent return love spell to get lost lover back... I\'m here today to say thanks to Dr.happy for the happiness he brought to my marriage
well!! I\'m Cassie Tiffany from texas, USA...I just found out about my husband cheating on me with a co-worker! We’ve been married going on two years. 2kids. lots of amazing momments together. i want to leave, but i love him so much. all i can think about is how nothing stopped him. how he has to see her everyday because they work together. we are both still young and very attractive. but i want my husband, my friend, and the father of my beautiful children. how do i get past the thought of another woman having my husband? Not my fiancé, not my boyfriend, but my husband! i still love him even though he thinks i want to leave i really want him to do better and stop me before i walk out! my husband told me that he doesn’t feel loved anymore, just because of this co-worker he has be cheating on with me that he wants a divorce, i was devastated, heart broken i begged him to listen to me that we can work it out like we always do, but he didn’t listen, he told me that he met someone that loves and understands him, i begged him to consider our kids but he’s did listen. he left and i was frustrated, i began searching for help and answers, then i heard about a man that can Cast a spell to remind him of all the things we have been through together, at first I was scared then i decided to give it a try, and like magic my husband came back, apology and begging for forgiveness, thanks to this man, I’m posting this to help people with similar issues. You can contact him for help too. [email protected] for more details Whatsapp and call...+2348133873774 You can also view on his Blogs site... https://happylovespell2.blogspot.com.ng/


Reply
Kate
12 Days ago

There are a lot of comments here and I do not have time to read them all but what it really comes down to is that it is the ranchers who get favor.They take over land that the horses live in and Who cares if the horses were introduced ? They do not cause harm (in my opinion) but the ranchers want more and more land for their cows. The more land the more cows. They are killing bison for this reason as the bison go out of the parks at the end of winter to grace and the ranches kill them as they have taken land right outside Yellowstone. Do not make horses suffer and/or die for the purposes of people. If there is a any species that is invasive it is our own. We are the ones who have completely upset the balance of nature and continue to destroy it on a daily basis.


Reply
Maggie Frazier
12 Days ago

My, this article certainly brought all the pros out of the woodwork with all of the same old propaganda!
Surprising that this site would be of interest to them.
Good article!


Reply
John PASQUA
13 Days ago

the bureau of land management needs to be humane to the great horses now.


Reply
Agropyron
3 Years Ago

Here is the scientific perspective of horses, which counters every single "fact" proposed in this completely dishonest article.
http://www.nrel.colostate.edu/assets/nrel_files/labs/aldridge-lab/publications/Beever&Aldridge_2011_Equids&GRSG_SAB_Ch14.pdf

http://www.cabnr.unr.edu/research/research_project.aspx?GrantID=709

http://www.spcru.ars.usda.gov/research/publications/Publications.htm?seq_no_115=278281&pf=1

http://joomla.wildlife.org/documents/policy/feral_horses_1.pdf

http://joomla.wildlife.org/documents/positionstatements/Feral.Horses.July.2011.pdf

http://joomla.wildlife.org/documents/policy/horse_comments_082010.pdf

http://www.berrymaninstitute.org/files/uploads/pdf/journal/ fall2011/4_Bies_horses_p171-172.pdf

http://connection.ebscohost.com/c/articles/67408253/wildlife-society-responds-cnn-report-feral-horses

http://www.enn.com/press_releases/3686

http://docs.house.gov/meetings/AP/AP06/20140410/101762/HHRG-113-AP06-Wstate-WilliamsB-20140410.pdf

http://news.wildlife.org/blog/perils-of-speaking-the-truth-about-feral-cats-and-horses/

http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1467-8306.1994.tb01737.x/abstract

http://news.wildlife.org/blog/why-celebrities-should-stay-out-of-resource-management-debates/

http://heinonline.org/HOL/Page?handle=hein.journals/envlnw15&div=29&g_sent=1& collection=journals#515

http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1467-8306.1994.tb01737.x/abstract

http://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-94-011-2868-1_24#page-1

http://heinonline.org/HOL/Page?handle=hein.journals/lawlr16&div=29&g_sent=1& collection=journals#535

http://joomla.wildlife.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=927

http://www.ava.com.au/policy/133-control-feral-horses-and-other-equidae


Reply
Melissa Ohlsson
20 Jan 2015

Agropyron, I didn\'t have to delve very far into the links you claim provide the "facts" to refute this "dishonest article"
The first, "fact" I came across was this:

"Spatial data for equid ranges were compiled from state and local BLM and USFS offices."

First off, if this particular document relied on information from the BLM state and local BLM and USFS offices, it is not acceptable. The BLM has publically acknowledged that they have no idea how many wild horses are on the range. They estimate, (aka: GUESS) that number to be 30 to 40,000 total. The agency could not produce any documentation to show that number was even an educated guess, because no data was accumulated. Advocates have learned from numerous BLM FOIA papers, that the BLM will monitor a section of range in Montana, then apply the results to whatever range they need statistics on.

For this reason alone, all roundup activity should cease until the BLM can do an accurate head count of how many wild horses they need to manage on the range and back that number up with credible scientific data.

Then there are statements like this:
"Free-roaming equids within these sagebrush eco-systems, as is true for all large-bodied herbivores, can alter ecosystem components directly through any of several processes, including selective plant consumption, trampling of plants and surface soil horizons, and spatial redistribution of nutrients via ingestion and subsequent excretion. Furthermore, relatively little consideration has been given to understanding links between the effects that free-roaming wild horses may have on sagebrush ecosystems and sagebrush-obligate species that these systems support."

What this cleverly avoids saying is that 100 cattle grazing within these sagebrush eco-systems will inflict far more damage than 10 wild horses, but no one thought it was an issue worth looking into.

Fossil evidence trumps your outdated belief that wild horses are an invasive species. Horses originated and evolved in North America. You might as well accept that FACT and bring your brain into the 21st century.

John Cox
16 Apr 2018

We call those links, you provided, Malicious Science. In another word it is specific in special interests combined with conflict of interests, as well as reek of political agenda, and from BLM or USDA. A small portion of ranchers, in AZ for example, have received $88.2 million in government subsidies (i.e. welfare ranchers who graze their cattle on Public Lands -- so can you imagine what they receive in taxpayer money nation wide) from 2006 to 2015 -- about a dozen cattle ranchers, actually. Do they have special interests in generating some of these types of non-science? Millions of dollars worth of special interests, and why we see a growth of Malicious Science throughout the USA currently.

But worse yet, ecology principles do not support the "Single-Species" (non-indigenous species) such as cattle. Then we go to the domestic receipts of sales, and find Welfare Ranching is merely less than 1% of sales domestically, and within the United States we have a throw-away margin, of beef products, at 34%. So why do we subsidize such awkward businesses as cattle ranchers on Public Lands? It simple is very destructive, through good science we find this out, to our forestry and public lands, and very provable.

John Cox
16 Apr 2018

I do not know what happened, but the figures in my statement garbled. . . . less than 1% of domestic market sales, . . . 34% throw-away margins of beef products . . . Please correct, or use these figures.

Harold Thomas
3 Years Ago

Horse and cattle are both intooduced species. Wild horses (mustangs) were brought to the Americas by the Spanish, then all the other Europeans. They are native to the Steppes of Russia. Cattle are a bovine species that approximate Bison in their grazing. The grasses of the American Plains coexisted with the Bison herd migrtations for eons. Horses are an inefficient pest. They eat multiple times the amount of a similar sized cow because they are NOT a ruminant. They do not add to the environemnt, but in fact are a scourge. They should all be eliminated from public land just like any other invasive species. You can trap them and slughter them or shoot them where they stand, but their eilination would be a step in the right direction in restoring the former status of the public lands.Let the congregation say Amen!


Reply
SusanMeansLily
13 Jan 2015

Amen!
BLM horses must be protected and MANAGED as per the Wild Free Roaming Horses & Burros Act. As long as the BLM horses are managed to their Appropriate Management Level, I don\'t have any problem with them being on Public Land. I actually like having them there. Right now, they have become a serious problem. This article is so full of inaccuracies I\'m just looking for the DONATE button, because you know it was put together by an organization that wants your money and will say whatever will get the public to donate their funds. On this particular article, the money-grubber is: American Wild Horse Preservation. (Send money now...the horses need you...LOL)

sharon
14 Jan 2015

sorry, but you are incorrect. horse petroglyphs from thousands of years ago have been found in the western US. these early horses, and additional horses that escaped from european explorers, peacefully coexisted with the other wildlife in the western US.

cattle currently grazing on the land are domesticated. left alone without humans to "protect" them from predators, they would not last long. they do not fit into the ecosystem, but are there because humans breed them and move them there every year to eat up all of the grass before they are sent to slaughter. then, more cattle are brought in the next year.

every statement in the article is a scientific fact. many scientists have studied this issue, and have published their results in scientific peer reviewed journals.

anyone can state their own opinion, but that opinion does not change the scientific facts.

Agropyron
3 Years Ago

WILD HORSES ARE NOT WILDLIFE. WESTERN ECOSYSTEMS DID NOT EVOLVE WITH PRESSURE FROM FERAL/WILD HORSES. HORSES ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR A MAJORITY OF THE UNMANAGED GRAZING ON PUBLIC LAND AND THE DAMAGE THAT RRESULTS. HORSES ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE DESTRUCTION OF THREATENED AND ENDANGERED SPECIES HABITAT. THE AUTHOR IS CLUELESS.
There is plenty of research and common sense to back up enerything I said, and counters every lie this author tried to pass off as fact. Notice all his citations from scientifi articles? No? Because the authors opinion is countered by science, not supported.


Reply
eric
3 Years Ago

This article is full of inaccuracies!


Reply
Agropyron
14 Jan 2015

The author is from Florida. Feral horses destroying the west and dieing in droves probably looks pretty good from Florida. Ahhhh, just sit back, sip that margarita and watch those beautiful horses convert another grass/forb community to shrubs and trees. Don\'t worry about the deer and the grouse and the antelope and the rabbits and birds, they will find someplace else to live. This is horse country!

Yes, sarcasms.

jamie thomson
3 Years Ago

I\'ve worked as a biologist on federal land that had feral horses which are protected under the Wild Horses and Burrows Act, but no cows, and it was amazing how much damage they had done to the ecosystem. This was a large military reservation where the mountain lion population was huge and still the horses were overpopulated. Wild horses are not wild. They are feral and, biologically speaking, should really be removed from all federal land.


Reply


Subscribe to our Newsletter




Follow us on


Do Not Show This Again

×

Submit to OneGreenPlanet


Terms & Conditions ×
  GET FOOD MONSTER APPX