Welcome Green Monsters! We're your online guide to making conscious choices that help people, animals and the planet.
Download food monster: the biggest, baddest, yummiest vegan food app!
Buy the #EatForThePlanet book



With the growing awareness being brought to the cruel treatment of animals raised on factory farms (thanks to undercover investigations!), more consumers are looking for “organic” and “free-range labels” on their meat and dairy products. The assumption being that animals raised on an organic farm are not raised under the same unsanitary and inhumane conditions. The illustrious organic farm is a place that calls to mind idyllic images of happy farmers and happy cows that take pride in producing milk and cheese for the American masses. While this is a lovely image and I truly do wish this is what life was actually like for farm animals, the real-life organic farm is more factory than fairy-tale.

In most cases, the “organic” label that is plastered to milk, yogurt, and cheese packaging is just a fancy sticker that only ensures that the cows who produced these products were fed strictly “organic” feed (i.e. organic corn that’s really not good for cows anyway). Some of the other regulations organic farmers must comply with include: allowing cows unrestricted access to pasture and no antibiotics or hormones are allowed, unless an animal is sick in which case it is treated and removed from the herd. You will note there aren’t any restrictions that would protect organic cows from cruel treatment or other inhumane practices typical of dairy production.

In a similar manner to the “small farm” appeal that entices animal lovers to give in and eat meat, the organic label on dairy is another cheap marketing ploy designed to make us feel better about our bad decisions.

1. Udder Infections Not Treated with Antibiotics

Organic dairy cows are mechanically milked 3 times a day and are expected to produce 10 times more milk than they would naturally. This intense burden on the cow’s metabolism make them highly susceptible to infection, especially when udders become raw from constant milking. This endless string of milk production frequently results in painful udder infections, called mastisis (the second leading cause of dairy cow death). Most commonly, these infections result from a strain of staph, which is actually made worse if treated with Iodine, an alternative to antibiotics. In some instances, an antibiotic is necessary to relieve the intense pain wrought from these infections, yet farmers refuse to utilize antibiotics and risk having to remove the cow from production.

Not only is mastitis extremely painful for cows, but milk from a sick cow will contain pus. Yum.

2. Mothers Separated from Calves Minutes after Birth

Like factory-farm cows, organic-farm cows are forced to experience the emotional distress of losing a child continuously until they are brought to slaughter. An organic dairy cow is seen as having one purpose in life: to produce milk  – not milk to feed her babies, but milk to sell to millions of Americans. How fulfilling! Because of this, dairy cows are artificially inseminated every year, only going a couple months in between pregnancies during their entire lifespan. Once the cow gives birth, her calf is immediately taken away from her so it doesn’t drink ANY of her precious money…sorry, I meant milk.

3. Cows Experience Stress when Isolated or Separated from Friends

Following the above point, when mother cows are separated from their calves, they become notably depressed, bellowing for extended periods of time, hiding in dark corners, and refusing to eat or drink. There has been a ton of research done into the emotional capacity of cows and all findings show that cows experience the same complex feelings we do. Cows exhibited heightened levels of cortisol (a stress hormone) and rapid heart rates when they are separated from family and friends. In fact, stressed cows produce less milk, compounding the pressure put on the animal to produce high-yields.

Not only does the organic mother cow experience distress in this process, but separation upon birth is incredibly traumatic to the calf. Female calves are raised as dairy cows, bound to the same sad fate as their mothers, but male calves have it worse. Minutes after birth, male calves are forced into “veal crates,” tight enclosures where their necks are chained to prevent any sort of motion and fed a diet of iron-filled fluids. They are slaughtered at 16 weeks old. Next time you see a label that boasts “milk-fed veal,” all that means is the calf was actually allowed to drink the milk it was intended to during its short life.

4. Crammed, Unclean Quarters

There is a common misunderstanding that just because organic cows are allowed unrestricted access to pasture, that that means they have lots of space to roam free. This is not the case. Cows on organic farms are usually confined in filthy sheds, where they live in their filth, so farmers can keep track of cows for frequent milking.

5. Feedlots and Fear Prior to Inhuman Slaughter

After a short four years of constant pregnancies and milking, organic dairy cows are shipped off to feedlots to be fattened up before they are slaughtered. Commonly, feedlots are factory farms, where organic cows are simply fed organic feed, while the other thousands of cows are given regular feed.

When organic dairy cows reach slaughter weight, they are brought to the same USDA regulated facilities as factory farm cows. These facilities are notorious for their cruel, inhumane treatment of animals. Being shoved into a metal floored room with thousands of other cows, the final moments of life for an organic cow is just as terrifying as it is for a factory farm cow. While it is required that cows be rendered unconscious before slaughter, the method of electrocuting animals until they pass out can hardly be considered a kind practice.

Less Bad Does NOT Mean Good

As you can see, while organic may be a better alternative to dairy that is filled with hormones and antibiotics, it is not a cruelty-free solution. If you really want to make a cow happy, ditch dairy all together and stop paying for the mistreatment of these sensitive animals. They might not be able to thank you themselves, so I will do it for them.


Image Source: I Can Has Cheezburger 

Want to read more posts like this? Sign up for our newsletter below!​

Browse through some recent posts below:

Why Feeding White Bread to Wild Birds is Killing Them

Feeding White Bread to Wild Birds is Killing Them

Why We Need to Teach Kids That Exotic Animals Are Not Pets or Toys

Why Its Important to Teach Kids That Exotic Animals Are Not Pets or Toys

14 Signs You Are Obsessed With Your Dog (In a Good Way!)

15 Signs You are Obsessed With Your Pooch (in a good way!)

Happy Dolphins? We Can’t Really Know: Statement on Study of Captive Dolphin Welfare

Disclosure: One Green Planet accepts advertising, sponsorship, affiliate links and other forms of compensation, which may or may not influence the advertising content, topics or articles written on this site. Click here for more information.

9 comments on “Are Organic Dairy Cows Actually Happier?”

Click to add comment
3 Years Ago

There\'s a lot of rubbish in this! Where do I start.
Most organic cows aren\'t milked 3x - they are milked 2x a day because they have to graze between times. Even if they are milked 3x, a calf will suckle its mother up to 6x a day so why is more milking bad? In robotic milking systems cows often choose to be milked more.
It is most certainly not in the farmer\'s interest for a cow to have mastitis as the cow is sick and if you want to be mercenary about it, she produces less. Incidence of mastitis in cows is not dissimilar to the incidence in humans in fact.
Separating cow from calf very soon after birth is better than leaving for a few days when the separation is very traumatic. No it\'s not ideal, but it\'s a dairy farm. Cow usually forget about a day afterwards, a calf within a few hours, especially as they form relationships with humans and other calves. Actually, they do get their mother\'s milk - the colostrum - which is very important for their health. You are right on the research about separating cows, but why would they be? Your point is a bit bizarre. I can\'t comment on US veal raising but certainly in the EU, calves must be group housed, have space to play and run around, and be fed an iron rich diet.
How can you have unrestricted access to pasture yet be confined in a shed? wrong wrong wrong.
It is not in anyone\'s interests for a shed to be filthy - see mastitis point above. And farmers get penalised for dirty milk, so again, please get your facts right. You clearly have a vegan agenda and are unable to look constructively at anything concerning farm animals.

10 Nov 2016

They do have a vegan agenda. Their recipe submission page clear states "Recipes submitted MUST be vegan".

Diane Marcina
4 Years Ago

Cows living outside full time, w/shelter if they choose. On pasture and good quality hay, no chemicals used to grow either. No chemicals given to the cows at all. A bit of organic grain waiting for them in the milking parlor. Their calves left w/them and weaned at 6 months plus. Producing milk until well into their teens. Kept until they die naturally. WTH is wrong w/that life?????? It's better than a lot of people. You must stop anthropomorphizing

Wendy Darling
4 Years Ago

Nope! Mother and child are still separated. There is no such thing as happy meat or humane slaughter. Animals do not want to die.

Claude William Genest
4 Years Ago

You sure are painting that picture with a mighty broad brush ! Maybe get out of the city a bit and come visit some nice small, local, organic farms. Plenty of happy, healthy, and beloved animals in that model.

James Mork
4 Years Ago

I wonder what makes cows happy. There must be some sort of daily life that is relaxing and healthy. We can guess being locked into a restraint with feed in front of you and sucking machines attached to the rear end isn't ideal. Humans ought to make a mental picture of themselves in that captive state and see if good emotions come. We used to joke at work that our bosses would really like us chained to our chairs with catheters so we would have to take bathroom breaks. As satire, it was funny, but no one choose anything like that just because of "productivity".

Kirsten Lassen-Smith
4 Years Ago

Another dirty dairy secret that needs to be told to stop their suffering for us :-(

Marcella Ann Dolan
4 Years Ago


Louise Marie Gross
4 Years Ago

Thank you for the information! Wish the law regulated such treatment.

Allison Aevaliotis
4 Years Ago

Thank you

Amanda Hoffman
4 Years Ago

Organic refers only to what the animal ate and whether it was given hormones and antibiotic treatments. Nothing to do with the environment the animal lives and dies in.

21 Nov 2016

Organic refers also to their environment, ensuring that they meat their natural behavioour as close as possible and that their welfare (e.g. stress-free, balanced diet, unrestricted movement). Similarly, even their transport and slaugther has to be handled in such a way that the animals suffer as little stress as possible. Obviously you have no interest on knowing about it, you only want to prove your point as vegan

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Follow us on

Do Not Show This Again


Submit to OneGreenPlanet

Terms & Conditions ×