An alarming video of the horse carriage running a red light and almost colliding with a wheelchair-bound individual has surfaced. This is just one example of the reckless actions that go unchecked in the industry as horses are overworked in horrible conditions. Despite city regulations and guidelines, the lack of stringent enforcement allows such violations to persist. The consequences of these actions can be life-threatening, posing serious risks to both the vulnerable horses and the public.
🚨DANGER: Carriage driver nearly hits person in wheelchair while talking on cellphone & plowing through red light at 59th St!
Every day horses and the public are put in deadly danger in Midtown traffic while @NYCSpeakerAdams @Lynn4NYC @NYCMayor turn a blind eye. #RydersLaw pic.twitter.com/iu7LxnWCdl
— NYCLASS (@nyclass) July 17, 2023
For decades, animal rights activists and concerned citizens have raised alarm about the well-being of these horses amidst the hustle and bustle of city life. Horses as naturally skittish animals, can be easily overwhelmed by the constant noise, traffic, and Pollution, putting their physical and mental health at risk.
Moreover, the carriage rides themselves can be perilous for passengers and pedestrians alike. Traffic violations, like the incident on 59th Street, are not isolated occurrences. Many drivers, under pressure to cater to tourists’ demands, have been known to flout traffic rules and prioritize speed over the safety of every being involved.
Amidst the release of this video, advocates, elected officials, and animal rights groups have gathered to mark the first anniversary of the introduction of Ryder’s Law, which seeks to replace horse-drawn carriages with modern electric alternatives.
Representatives from NYCLASS have taken the lead in demanding action to end the horse carriage industry’s cruel practices. Councilmember Robert Holden, the sponsor of Ryder’s Law, emphasizes the importance of embracing modern alternatives like electric carriages to ensure animal welfare and provide better working conditions for carriage drivers. The aim is not to abolish the tradition entirely but to transition it into a more humane and sustainable practice that benefits everyone involved.
One major issue contributing to the ongoing abuse of carriage horses is outdated legislation. Section 353 of the Agriculture and Markets law, written in the 19th Century, fails to address the complexities and challenges of modern urban life. The term “overdriving,” listed as a violation of law, is now proving insufficient to protect the well-being of carriage horses in a bustling city like Manhattan. The need for an updated and comprehensive set of laws and regulations that addresses the current realities of horse-drawn carriages has become evident.
Sign this petition to end horse carriage rides in New York City!
Easy Ways to Help the Planet:
Get your favorite articles delivered right to your inbox! Sign up for daily news from OneGreenPlanet.
Help keep One Green Planet free and independent! Together we can ensure our platform remains a hub for empowering ideas committed to fighting for a sustainable, healthy, and compassionate world. Please support us in keeping our mission strong.

Comments: