Welcome Green Monsters! We're your online guide to making conscious choices that help people, animals and the planet.
Download food monster: the biggest, baddest, yummiest vegan food app!
Buy the #EatForThePlanet book



You thought your darling cats and dogs were safe from hungry, greedy meat-loving maniacs? Think again! Laws governing the consumption of dog and cat meat – and the killing of pets for consumption – vary state to state in the U.S.. According to Dogster, “Federal food safety law makes it illegal for slaughterhouses to process dogs and cats. That takes care of where the vast majority of Americans get their meat. It does not, however, cover home meat-slaughtering operations.”

Really? So torturing a dog or cat is animal cruelty, but in some states killing and eating your pets is a-ok? You’ve got to be kidding me!

Thankfully, lawmakers in the state of Pennsylvania are pushing for a bill (passed in the House unanimously) to close this loophole and make it illegal to breed, process, slaughter, or sell dogs or cats for human consumption.

According to Philly.com “Only about a half-dozen states, among them New Jersey and New York, have laws specifically barring the butchering of dogs and cats. ‘Most of the general public assumes this is already illegal,’ said Adam Parascandola, director of animal cruelty response for the Humane Society of the United States … Parascandola said he had only heard of sporadic cases in the United States of dogs or cats being used for meat, and under standard laws the killing is legal if not done in a cruel manner.”

Slate.com recently covered the issue in their article, “Is it legal to eat your cat?” Here’s a summary of some state laws on killing and eating your cat or dog, via Slate:

  • The state of New York expressly prohibits “any person to slaughter or butcher domesticated dog (canis familiaris) or domesticated cat (felis catus or domesticus) to create food, meat or meat products for human or animal consumption.” The law also doesn’t cover ferrets, gerbils, parakeets, or other less familiar pet species.
  • California’s anti-pet-eating law has a broader reach. It bars possession of the carcass, so having bought your cat steaks from someone else wouldn’t be a useful alibi. The California law also protects “any animal traditionally or commonly kept as a pet or companion,” rather than just Fido and Fluffy…Horses are specifically covered by a different section of the code. There’s no precedent on iguanas, goldfish, or boa constrictors.
  • Virginia, bars the unnecessary killing of an animal, with a specific exemption for “farming activities.” In those places, it’s very likely that killing a cat for dinner would get you in trouble, because the killing wouldn’t be necessary, and cats aren’t commonly associated with farming.

As surprising as this revelation may be, it once again brings to light the confusion of why we choose some animals as companions, and some as our food. Some people keep pigs as pets, while others see them only as food. Why have we created such a distinction? We applaud the Pennsylvania legislature for protecting our pets from becoming dinner, and perhaps one day, we can applaud the moment when other animals are afforded the same respect.

Is some consistency in the way we deal with animals too much to ask for, people?

Image Source: Wikimedia Commons

Want to read more posts like this? Sign up for our newsletter below!​

Browse through some recent posts below:

Victory! India Banned Live Export After Public Protest

Helsinki Fashion Week Banned Leather Because Wearing Dead Animals Is Going Out of Style!

Cow Desperately Reaching for Fresh Air in a Transport Truck Will Change How You Feel About Our Food System

Lamb Found In a Field Surrounded By Others Who Didn’t Make it Is Finally Learning What it Means to Be Safe

Disclosure: One Green Planet accepts advertising, sponsorship, affiliate links and other forms of compensation, which may or may not influence the advertising content, topics or articles written on this site. Click here for more information.

One comment on “WTF? Selling Dogs or Cats for Human Consumption is Legal in Most U.S. States!”

Click to add comment
3 Years Ago

As someone who lived overseas for a while and tried dog meat...and who also owns a dog...the only way I\'d choose to eat my pet is if that was literally the only food left to me.

Dog meat isn\'t good. Only the super-poor eat it, because that\'s all they can afford. If someone genuinely wants to eat dog meat in the US, then that\'s weird. If a poor person in China wants to eat it, then I\'m not going to deny them that.

Bogna Komar
3 Years Ago

Eating meat of human best friends ? It means betray them . It`s not only disgusting but a crime as well . High developed country !!!!!XD

Margaret O\'Bryan
3 Years Ago

Unfortunately, due to pressure from the NRA, it is still legal to eat dogs and cats in Pennsylvania. Totally disgusting that they gave in to NRA pressure.

4 Years Ago

“All animals have the same capacity for suffering, but how we see them differs and that determines what we’ll tolerate happening to them. In the western world, we feel it wrong to torture and eat cats and dogs, but perfectly acceptable to do the same to animals equally as sentient and capable of suffering. No beings who pride themselves on rationality can continue to support such behaviour.”- Twyla Francois

Nick Pierson
15 Jan 2015

There are hundreds of thousands of dogs and cats starving to death on the streets due to overpopulation. Even with modern tactics to prevent the overpopulation of these pets, they continue to reproduce at an unsustainable rate. If I were a dog or cat, I would much rather encounter a quick death that meant something, like keeping another creature alive, than enduring weeks of torturous starvation with a death that means absolutely nothing. I know what website I am posting this comment on and I acknowledge that many of you find my words reprehensible, but please think about it. If you had to make the choice between a dog and a starving child, which would you pick?

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Follow us on

Do Not Show This Again


Submit to OneGreenPlanet

Terms & Conditions ×