Welcome Green Monsters! We're your online guide to making conscious choices that help people, animals and the planet.
Download food monster: the biggest, baddest, yummiest vegan food app!
Buy the #EatForThePlanet book



Taking a horse-drawn carriage ride around Central Park has been lauded as one of the most romantic activities any New Yorker (or tourist) can experience. Riding around the park, seemingly separated from the thick smog of taxi and bus fumes, a horse-drawn carriage is a much coveted escape from the reality of fast-moving city life. This is of course, from the perspective of the well-looked after rider … the same can’t exactly be said for the poor creature who has been tasked with pulling you around for an hour and a half (two if you pay extra!).

New York City carriage horses are some of the city’s most forgotten residents. By nature, horses don’t belong within the concrete bounds of New York City, horses belong in wide open spaces where they can run, graze, and be a horse. However, NYC carriage horses are deprived of this life and given in place a life of abuse, neglect, and exhaustion.

Bobby II A.K.A. Horse “2873”

Bobby II is a horse who knows the life of a carriage horse first hand. Bobby II’s story begins in at the West Side Livery Stable on West 38th Street in New York City, where he was held when he was not working as a carriage horse. Serving seven years as a carriage horse, Bobby II was simply worn out.

There are over 200 horses currently serving as carriage horses in New York City. These animals are forced to work nine hour days, dragging heavy carts in every type of weather. Carriage horses are constantly exposed to car exhaust and city pollution. As you could imagine, having horses walking literally in between speeding cars, taxis and buses is incredibly dangerous. New York City has the highest number of horse-drawn carriage accidents in the country.

Susan Wagner, the founder of Equine Advocates, explains,”I don’t think any urban carriage horse in New York City is treated well. Their lives are totally unnatural… They live nose-to-tailpipe existences, inhaling the fumes and being surrounded by crowds and vehicles. They hear sirens, emergency vehicles and are sometimes hit or swiped by buses and other vehicles – none of this is natural or humane for horses.”

A Last Minute Rescue

After years of wear and tear, Bobby II became lame and was sent to an Amish farm in New Holland, Pennsylvania. According to the Coalition to Ban Horse-Drawn Carriages, this particular area of Pennsylvania is infamous for livestock auctions that cater to slaughter houses. Many horses that age out of the carriage horse business are sent to slaughter, and it is very rare that one is rescued before slaughter. NYC carriage horses can be identified by a serial number that is carved into their hooves, but to keep up appearances, these numbers are usually filed off the hoof before they are sent to auction, and thereafter slaughter.

Wagner explains to OGP, “The carriage horse operator who owned and worked him in New york City told the New York Times, ‘It got too old,'” which is why he deserted Bobby. Wagner continues, “He was referred to as ‘it’ as though he were not even alive.”

It is estimated that NYC drivers send around 71 horses a year to auction, removing their serial numbers so animal rights advocates can’t identify where these sick and visibly abused horses come from. Bobby II is an exception from this sad slaughter circle for two reasons, first and foremost he was rescued, and second at the time of rescue, his serial number was still intact.

While his serial number is what defined him as a carriage horse, it is also what saved his life. A woman in New Holland spotted Bobby’s number and quickly took a photo and posted it on an Internet alert. Elizabeth Forel, an advocate with the Coalition to Ban Horse Drawn Carriages, was able to identify Bobby based on records kept by the New York Department of Health, and promptly set to action to rescue this former carriage horse. Bobby had already been sold for slaughter, but there was a brief window in which he could be resold before he was shipped off. With the help of Friends of Animals, Forel was able to raise a sum of $800 to purchase Bobby and arranged to have him moved to Wagner’s Equine Advocates Rescue and Sanctuary, in Chatham, New York.

After Serving Seven Years as a Carriage Horse, Bobby II Gets a Lifelong Vacation at Safe Home Equine Sanctuary

Wagner tells OGP, when Bobby II went to the vet hospital before he arrived at the sanctuary, it was discovered, “he had gone lame on his right side,” additionally, “he was filled with worms.”

Bobby’s face was also covered in scars, Wagner explains this was from, “the severe equipment that he was forced to wear. The equipment is put on tightly on all the horses so as to induce pain. Urban carriage horses are controlled with pain.”

After Serving Seven Years as a Carriage Horse, Bobby II Gets a Lifelong Vacation at Safe Home Equine Sanctuary

However, just a few days after he arrived at the sanctuary, his scars began to fade. Wagner and her fellow Equine Advocates could not love Bobby II any more. Just watch the incredible video of Bobby II’s first steps onto his new sanctuary home:


As Wagner explains, this is the first time this horse has ever gotten to freely graze on grass, let alone run free or roll around in it.  Wagner writes on the Equine Advocate website, “As soon as he got off the trailer, we could see what a kind and gentle soul he was. ”

Bobby II’s transformation has been incredible. He not only looks visibly healthier, but he has made friends and is allowed to express his kind and loving personality in a way he never was before.

After Serving Seven Years as a Carriage Horse, Bobby II Gets a Lifelong Vacation at Safe Home Equine Sanctuary

Wagner tells OGP, “Bobby is unlike any horse we have here because he is so in tune to people…It’s almost as though he knows what you are saying…and I think that is because what he did for seven years is listen to people’s voices.”

While it is unfortunate that Bobby had to endure so much pain to develop this skill, it is also what makes him the favorite among sanctuary visitors, “He defintiely knows is name and he is one the few equines here who we can have freely interacting with children of all ages, as he is a very gentle guy.”

After Serving Seven Years as a Carriage Horse, Bobby II Gets a Lifelong Vacation at Safe Home Equine Sanctuary

Unlike many other carriage horses, Bobby has finally been given a break from work. Carriage horses rarely get a week-long vacation, let alone the chance to live out their lives being served by humans rather than being forced to serve them.

After Serving Seven Years as a Carriage Horse, Bobby II Gets a Lifelong Vacation at Safe Home Equine Sanctuary

Wagner tells OGP that in his retirement, “Bobby loves to eat. He will eat anything you give him, but he mostly loves apples and carrots.”

Surely, in the good care of Equine Advocates, Bobby will be given all the apples and carrots his heart desires…if not more!

To learn more about the NYC carriage horse program, and what you can do to end this cruel practice, click here. To learn more about Equine Advocates, check out their website and Facebook page.

Want to read more posts like this? Sign up for our newsletter below!​

Browse through some recent posts below:

Reality Check: Factory Farm Workers Average 2 Amputations a Week Due to Dangerous Conditions

Reality Check: Factory Farm Workers Average 2 Amputations a Week Due to Dangerous Conditions

USDA Killed Over 1.3 Million Non-Invasive Animals in 2017, But Can You Guess Why?

Southern Resident Orca Populations Are the Lowest in 30 Years, and Humans Are to Blame

How Bee Saving Paper May Give Bumbling Insects a Fighting Chance

Disclosure: One Green Planet accepts advertising, sponsorship, affiliate links and other forms of compensation, which may or may not influence the advertising content, topics or articles written on this site. Click here for more information.

0 comments on “After Serving Seven Years as a Carriage Horse, Bobby II Goes to an Equine Sanctuary”

Click to add comment
Hold Your Horses
3 Years Ago

So much about this article is wrong. So many assumptions are made by the \'rescuers\', and the hardship is exadurated to make the life of a carriage horse seem worse than it is. Bobby II certainly had eaten grass before. All carriage horses are sent to pasture for several weeks a year. It\'s the law. If Bobby II\'s \'scars\' started to fade immediately, they weren\'t scars. They were rubs. The horse had no sores, and he was fat. If animal activists like this would work WITH the carriage owners, deals could be struck for each retiring horse. Instead, the activists, who seem to be totally lacking in diplomatic skills, make the carriage horse owners prefer to deal with even kill buyers instead. There is no one to blame for a carriage horse being sent to an auction but the activists who\'s rants and untrue propganda is more disturbing than what the carriage drivers do. As for the carriage driver calling the horse \'It\', isn\'t it likely that he was from another country- as most of the drivers are, and made that grammatical error? My life is dedicated to saving horses- but I do try to stick with saving only the horses who actually need saving. Most of the NYC carriage horses are fit, healthy, sound, and happy. I have checked each of them as the pass, or stand in front of my apartment there. Their ears are up, their eyes are bright, and their steps are lively. They are given grain and water while on duty, are well groomed, and well fitted with tack. There are very few exceptions. Advocates lead. Activists shove. There is a big difference.

Susan Humphrey
3 Years Ago

Buck Brannaman, the inspiration for Robert Redford\'s movie "The Horse Whisperers," and the most famous horse trainer in the country, recounts this story about the carriage horses and a visit to New York in his book "The Faraway Horses:"

"Next on my schedule were a couple of young women from MTV and Rolling Stone magazine. One of them asked, “What about those poor horses in Central Park? Don’t you think it’s awful how they have to pull those heavy carriages all day?”

I had an answer for that question “No, I don’t,” I said, then explained that the Central Park horses are content. Pulling carriages on rubber-rimmed wheels on paved streets is a low-stress job, and the horses are calm and relaxed, not anxiously laying their ears back or wringing their tails. Plus, these horses get lots of attention and affection from passerby. And horses love attention and affection as much as we do.

The horses that people should be concerned about are the neglected ones that, after the “newness” of ownership wears off, live in box stalls all day. These horses have no purpose, no jobs to do. All they do is eat and make manure. Even prisoners get to exercise more than these horses, and the horses have never done anything wrong. If they had the choice, these horses would choose to be carriage horses rather than stand in their stalls."

Brannaman is famous all over the world for his advocacy of humane and positive treatment of horses. It is really conceivable that this horse whisperer would condone the abuse, overwork and suffocation of working horses?

Equine Advocates
17 Aug 2014

With all due respect to Buck Brannaman and his wonderful ability to work with horses, we completely disagree with him on this issue. I don\'t think he knows all the facts about the urban carriage horse trade. We know firsthand what happened to Bobby and the condition he was in when he ended up in a kill pen after he could no longer work and turn a profit. Mr. Brannaman has never taken a public stand against horse slaughter. Why not? With our horses, we only use professionals who are openly opposed to horse slaughter, including our equine veterinarian. According to FOIA Reports, 60-70 NYC carriage horses disappear off the rolls every year without a trace. Where do you suppose they go?

Beth Verneris
3 Years Ago

How is Bobby II doing? I can see he\'s MUCH happier! Bless your hearts. I\'m going to chech out the site on banning the carriage rides. Never liked the idea.

Equine Advocates
16 Aug 2014

Bobby is doing great. He is a very happy boy living his life in a huge pasture and in the company of other horses which is as it should be. All horses deserve kind and humane treatment during their lives and a peaceful dignified end.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Follow us on

Do Not Show This Again


Submit to OneGreenPlanet

Terms & Conditions ×