Petition: An Officer Was Reviewing Footage for a Protection Order. She Found Him Throwing His Dog.

On a Saturday evening in DeLand, Florida, police went to an address on South Hill Avenue about a protection order. Someone had reported a violation, and an officer sat down to go through the property’s surveillance footage looking for evidence of it.

She found something else. Earlier that same day, the camera had recorded a small dog sitting on a golf cart outside the house. A man gets off the cart, takes the dog by its collar, lifts it into the air, swings it, and throws it to the ground. The dog lands hard and rolls across the pavement. He walks over, takes it by the collar again, and carries it inside.

Christopher Arthur Whitley was arrested and charged with animal cruelty and with violating the protection order. He was booked into the Volusia County Jail on no bond. He has been charged, not convicted, and the case sits with the State Attorney for Florida’s Seventh Judicial Circuit.

Sign the Petition

The two charges arriving together is the part that deserves attention, because the link between domestic violence and animal abuse is one of the better established findings in this field. Animals in violent households are frequently harmed as a way of controlling the people who love them, and victims routinely delay leaving because they have nowhere to take a pet. A case file that contains both a protection order and a dog thrown onto concrete is not two unrelated incidents that happened at one address. It is one pattern with two victims.

It also only exists because a camera happened to be pointed at the right part of the driveway, and because somebody was already looking at the footage for an unrelated reason. Nobody reported the dog. No neighbour saw it, or if they did, nobody called. Had the protection order complaint not been made that evening, this would simply not be a case.

The dog is now in the DeLand Police Department’s own kennels, because when officers arrived nobody at the scene could take custody of it. According to the police account it showed no visible injuries, which is worth stating plainly rather than overclaiming: this animal was thrown to the ground and appears to have come through it physically intact.

Add Your Name

What the petition asks the State Attorney for is a prosecution that does not quietly end in a plea and a fine, plus a lifetime ban on animal ownership and court-ordered counselling. The ban matters because the alternative is the dog going back. The counselling matters because of what the second charge suggests about where this behaviour sits. Florida allows animal cruelty to be charged as a misdemeanour or a felony depending on circumstances, and cases that look like this one frequently settle at the lower end. Our coverage of what dogs actually need from the households they live in assumes a home that is safe to begin with, which is an assumption this case breaks.

More Petitions to Sign

• The Dothan Grooming Shop Had No Power Since June. The Cats Were Still Inside.
• Sweetie the Husky Passed Every Welfare Check in Merced. She Kept Being Sent Back.
• He Was Banned From Owning Dogs. Goose Creek Found 35 of Them and Four Graves.