Want to reach our audience?
Plenty of houses have a chimney breast with nothing in it. The fire was taken out decades ago, the flue was capped, and what remains is an alcove that collects picture frames. Putting a gas fire back costs thousands and needs a flue survey, a fitter and a gas safety certificate. An electric insert drops into the same opening, plugs into a socket, and runs without combustion of any kind, which EPA indoor air quality guidance treats as a meaningful difference in a sealed room. That is a genuinely useful thing, and it is also not the energy upgrade the marketing implies, because what you are buying is a 1,500 watt heater with a picture of a flame on the front.
Decide first which of three things you are actually buying, because they install completely differently. A log set drops into an existing fireplace opening and needs nothing but a socket. A recessed linear unit is cut into a stud wall and is a building job. A freestanding stove sits on the floor and moves house with you. The log set is the one that keeps a disused chimney breast in service rather than ripping it out, and it is also the cheapest.
Heat output is quoted in watts and should be read in square feet. Touchstone states that its 1,500 watt heater produces around 5,000 BTU and covers roughly 400 square feet, which is a normal living room and nothing more. Any listing implying one of these will warm a house is describing a different appliance. Two settings are standard, usually 750 and 1,500 watts, and the lower one is the one you will use most.
Check whether the flame runs independently of the heat, because this is the feature that decides whether the thing gets used in June. Every unit in this roundup can display flames with the heating element off, drawing a few watts for the LEDs instead of 1,500 for the element. A fireplace that only works as a heater is a fireplace that sits dark for seven months.
Then look at infrared versus fan-forced, which changes how the room feels rather than how much it costs. Infrared warms objects and people directly and dries the air less, a distinction radiant heat transfer research describes in terms of how energy reaches a surface rather than the air between. Fan-forced pushes warm air around and heats the room faster but is audible. Duraflame sells both, and the choice is genuinely personal rather than technical.
All you need is an existing fireplace and an outlet, which is the whole appeal. The Duraflame DFI030ARU is a fully assembled faux log set with an infrared heater rated for 1,000 square feet, a realistic ember bed and a fire grate, and it goes from box to burning in about five minutes. Around $130 to $190. It only works if you already have an opening to put it in, and the 1,000 square foot figure assumes a well-insulated room rather than a draughty Victorian front room with a capped flue above it. Check current price.
Thirty ember and flame colour combinations, WiFi and Alexa control, and a thermostat that actually holds a temperature. The Touchstone Sideline 50 recesses into a wall for a flush finish and ships with both a log set and glass crystals so you can pick traditional or contemporary. Typically $450 to $650. Recessing means cutting into a stud wall and running a dedicated circuit, so budget for an electrician on top of the purchase price. See it on Amazon.
The sound is the part people do not expect to care about and then do. The Duraflame crackling log set adds an audible crackle to LED flames over a 1,000 square foot infrared heater, which gets considerably closer to a real fire than the visuals alone manage. Around $150 to $210. The crackle is a short loop and some owners switch it off within a week, so treat it as a feature you may stop using rather than a reason to pay more. View product details.
Sixty inches of flame across an open-plan wall changes a room in a way a small insert cannot. The Touchstone Sideline 60 is the same smart platform as the 50 with more width, thirty colour options and the same 1,500 watt heater. Usually $600 to $850. Note that the heater does not scale with the width: a 60 inch unit warms the same 400 square feet as a 50 inch one, so you are buying appearance rather than output. Check availability.
The Touchstone Sideline 72 is six feet of recessed linear flame with log and crystal hearth options and full app control, and it is the one to specify if the fireplace is meant to be the focal point of the room. Around $800 to $1,100. This is a significant amount of money for a supplemental heater, and at this price the honest comparison is against a proper heating upgrade rather than against other electric fireplaces. Compare on Amazon.
Turn the central thermostat down, or none of this saves anything. Duraflame’s own marketing makes the claim carefully: use the heater in the rooms you use most and turn the thermostat down to save up to 15 percent on heating bills. The saving lives entirely in the second half of that sentence. Running a 1,500 watt heater while the boiler keeps the rest of the house at the same temperature increases your bill rather than reducing it, and Department of Energy guidance on thermostat setbacks is where the actual mechanism is explained.
Be realistic about efficiency, because this is where the category oversells itself. Electric resistance heating converts almost all the electricity into heat, which sounds impressive until you compare it with a heat pump that moves three or four units of heat for every unit of electricity it uses. Energy Star’s heating comparison lays that out plainly. An electric fireplace is not an efficiency upgrade. It is a convenient way to heat one room without burning anything in it.
That last part is the genuine argument and it is a good one. There is no flue, no gas supply, no carbon monoxide risk and no combustion products in the room, which is the same case our electric kettle roundup makes about the kitchen. Indoor gas combustion produces nitrogen dioxide and fine particulates, which public health agencies monitor closely in domestic settings, and removing a gas fire from a living room removes that source entirely.
Use the flame on its own through the shoulder seasons. The LEDs draw a trivial amount of power, the heater is the expensive part, and most of the pleasure of a fire in April is visual rather than thermal. If you want the room genuinely warmer for less money, our guide to thermal cameras will find you the draughts first, and sealing those costs a tube of filler rather than eight hundred dollars.
OneGreenPlanet is an Amazon Associate and earns from qualifying purchases.
Get your favorite articles delivered right to your inbox! Sign up for daily news from OneGreenPlanet.
Keep One Green Planet independent — chip in what you can, or become a member and get ad-free browsing, a voice in our community, and the good feeling of fueling a sustainable, healthier, and kinder world.
Comments: