Petition: She Told Deputies There Were Five Dogs. They Removed 36 Border Collies.

From the street, the house on SW Alligator Street in Palm City, Florida looked fine. Well-maintained, fenced, unremarkable. When Martin County deputies served a search warrant there in August 2026, they had to put on Tyvek protective suits before going inside. The owner, 62-year-old Paige O’Donnell, had told them there were no more than five dogs in the house. Investigators removed 36 Border Collies. Sheriff John Budensiek described what they found: dogs that are supposed to be black and white were solid black, because they were coated in faeces. Please sign the petition calling for the maximum charges the evidence supports.

✍  Sign the Petition

Prosecutors have already done what the petition asks. O’Donnell faces 72 counts in total: 36 felony counts of animal cruelty, one for each dog, and 36 misdemeanour counts of failing to provide proper exercise or air. Bond was set at $275,000, with a condition prohibiting her from owning or possessing any animal. That per-animal charging matters more than it sounds. Hoarding cases are frequently charged as a single count regardless of how many animals were involved, which lets a case with dozens of victims resolve like a case with one. Charging each dog separately is what makes the sentence proportionate to the scale, and it is the outcome worth pressing for in every case like this. She is charged and not convicted, and is entitled to due process.

Two details are worth sitting with. The first is that this was not a discovery, it was a negotiation. Deputies surveilled the house for days and repeatedly tried to persuade O’Donnell to let them see the animals; she eventually agreed to surrender one dog. The sheriff’s assessment was blunt, that she knew what she was doing and multiple people had tried to help her. That is the difference between hoarding as a mental health crisis and hoarding as sustained refusal, and it is the distinction courts struggle with most. The second is that this was the second hoarding case Martin County had handled in weeks, the other involving an elderly mail carrier accused of taking more than 100 cats and dogs from her own delivery route. Both were found because someone reported them. All 36 dogs are now with the Treasure Coast Humane Society undergoing evaluation, medical treatment and grooming, and their placement will be decided by the court as proceedings continue. One Green Planet’s guide on what to do if you suspect animal abuse in your neighborhood covers how to report a situation like this, and the case is reported by NBC Miami. A tidy front garden tells you nothing.

✍  Sign the Petition Now

Sign These Urgent Petitions!

• Petition: 15 Elephants Died in One Month. Cyanide Was in Their Systems. Nobody Agrees Where It Came From.
• Petition: Five of the 17 Puppies Died of Parvo. The SPCA Calls the Survivors the Miracle Nine.
• Petition: Troopers Found Dead Cats, Rabbits, Pigs and Goats on One Michigan Property. 27 Animals Were Still Alive.