In light of the Coronavirus, we are seeing first hand how wildlife trade and meat consumption are related to infectious diseases and the deadly risk it poses to public health. It is therefore critical for governments to enforce stricter welfare standards for commercially-raised animals and ensure food safety is a priority.
Unfortunately, this is not the case.
The biggest Animal protection groups in the country came together and sued Secretary of Agriculture Sonny Perdue and the Department of Agriculture on February 11, 2020, for failing to protect pigs who are too sick, downed or injured to walk (also referred to as nonambulatory disabled or NAD pigs) at slaughterhouses, posing serious risks to animals and human health. They are collectively demanding rule-makers to improve food safety, animal handling, and inspector efficiency at slaughter establishments.
In 2002, Congress amended the Humane Methods of Slaughter Act—which governs not just the slaughter of animals but also their handling at the slaughterhouse—to direct the Secretary of Agriculture to investigate and report to Congress on a host of issues related to nonambulatory livestock, including humane handling, and to put into effect any regulations needed to protect these animals. However, despite the amended passage of nearly two decades, there is no indication that the USDA has ever reported on nonambulatory pigs, even though pigs comprise approximately 75% of livestock slaughter in the U.S.
The lawsuit, filed in federal court in Rochester, New York, challenges the agency’s failure to follow Congress’s longstanding mandates regarding these “downed” or “non-ambulatory” animals, as well as its recent denial of a petition to ban their slaughter. Plaintiffs are Farm Sanctuary, Animal Legal Defense Fund, Animal Outlook, Animal Welfare Institute, Compassion in World Farming, Farm Forward, and Mercy For Animals. They are represented by the Animal Law Litigation Clinic at the Center for Animal Law Studies at Lewis & Clark Law School.
Food Safety and Public Health Risks
124.4 million pigs were slaughtered in the US in 2018 and we’re on track to have a record year for pork production in 2020. Over 4 Percent or more than half a million pigs arrive at U.S. slaughterhouses too sick or injured to stand or walk. These animals are often kept in holding pens where they are unable to rise from feces-ridden floors before being slaughtered. Downed pigs are at a heightened risk of carrying a host of human-transmissible pathogens, including Listeria, Campylobacter, Salmonella, Swine Flu, and Yersinia.
A Pork Industry Institute-funded study found that 53.8% of nonambulatory pigs were actively infected with H1N1 and 51.9% were actively infected with H3N2. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention estimates that the H1N1 pandemic sickened 60.8 million Americans, hospitalized 274,304, and killed over 12,500.
In addition, pigs who are too sick or injured to stand are far more likely to harbor disease. “Lameness” an abnormality common to NAD pigs causes several bacterial and viral diseases like Listeria which contributes to an estimated 28% of U.S. foodborne illness deaths. Erysipelothrix rhusiopathiae, a bacterial infection that can cause human septic arthritis, endocarditis, and meningitis. Brucellosis, one of the most common zoonotic diseases. Porcine spongiform encephalopathy, the pig equivalent to mad cow disease. Various other bacterial infections that cause human joint and bone infections, pneumonia, fatal endocarditis, zoonoses for workers, all present as lameness in pigs.
Courtesy of Farm Sanctuary
How Inhumane Treatment of Animal Leads to Disease
Another major concern these groups have is that the slaughter of downed livestock creates an incentive and a heightened risk of inhumane handling, including being excessively electro-shocked, prodded, kicked, shoved, and dragged by workers attempting to force them to move ― which exceptionally increases disease risk.
In 2009, USDA required that all NAD mature cattle be promptly euthanized because livestock producers may hold ill or injured cattle from slaughter longer which creates incentives to inhumanely force these animals to rise. However, these groups believe that allowing the slaughter of NAD livestock, in fact, encourages inhumane handling of livestock for the same reasons. Producers are incentivized to hold ill or injured cattle from slaughter longer in an attempt to allow them to sufficiently recover to pass inspection, creating an incentive for establishments to inhumanely force these animals to rise.
Industry studies show that inhumane handling causes pigs to become non-ambulatory. The American Meat Institute cites data showing that 34% of pigs become fatigued when subject to aggressive handling with hot shots. An Elanco Animal Health-funded study found that pigs held in small pens are twice as likely to become non-ambulatory as pigs held in large pens. Another study shows that when workers use electrical prods on over 60% of pigs, four times more pigs become non-ambulatory.
Similarly, inhumane transportation practices cause pigs to become non-ambulatory, yet transporters continue to overcrowd pigs in trucks, despite research showing that pigs given one more square foot of space are seven times less likely to become non-ambulatory.
Warning: the video below contains distressing content. Please use discretion.
Financial Incentives for Establishments
Establishments have a strong incentive to hold NAD pigs for as long as it takes them to rise since a NAD pig that rises is worth at least $38 more than a pig that does not rise ― this increased lairage time will make NAD pigs at least 3-9 times more likely to contract Salmonella.
Establishments want to gain the full slaughter value of the pig. And even if the pig remains non-ambulatory, it is still worth roughly 70% the value of an ambulatory pig. As a result, the prevalence of non-ambulatory pigs has tripled.
“The federal government continues to treat pigs as industrial commodities to be produced as cheaply as possible, without regard for animal welfare or consumer safety,” said Irene Au-Young, a student in the Animal Law Litigation Clinic who is representing the plaintiffs. “The law doesn’t allow this total disregard, and this lawsuit will hold the government accountable for forcing sick and injured animals to the killing floor and onto the dinner plates of unsuspecting consumers.”
Courtesy of Farm Sanctuary
USDA’s Lack of Action
FSIS inspector Dr. Dean Wyatt testified before Congress that slaughter establishments screened off unloading areas so that FSIS could not document humane handling violations. He also testified that he had repeatedly been told not to prepare noncompliance records or take other enforcement actions, even after witnessing workers punching a NAD pig in the face and nose 8-12 times.
As reported verbatim in the complaint:
After the pig fell to the ground, the workers continued to drive another pig over the top of the nonambulatory pig. The ambulatory pig began running, trampling the non-ambulatory pig. FSIS suspended the establishment, but the next day held the suspension in abeyance, allowing the establishment to resume operations.
Just 16 days later, at the same establishment, a worker put a knock hole in a NAD pig‘s head and loaded the pig—bleeding and fully conscious—into a cart without the FSIS inspector noticing. The worker then wheeled the disabled pig to another pen, where another worker shackled the pig‘s leg and began to drag the conscious pig to the hanging area. At this point the inspector intervened, rescuing the pig, which was still rhythmically breathing and blinking her eyes, and ensured the pig was euthanized. The inspector then allowed the pig to be shackled, hung, and processed for human consumption. FSIS reinstated its suspension of the plant, but held it in abeyance two working days later, allowing slaughter operations to resume.
What These Groups Seek
- Prohibit the slaughter of NAD pigs to improve compliance with its food safety and humane handling mandates.
- Ensure that adulterated meat is not sold and that animals are handled in accordance with the HMSA.
- There should be no valid reasons for treating NAD pigs differently from NAD mature cattle and veal calves
This reform would reduce the risk of meat contamination, end the uncertainty about how to deal with NAD pigs, improve the efficiency of the inspection process, and decrease the multiple incentives for inhumane treatment of animals on farms, during transport, and at slaughter.
How You Can Help!
First and foremost, you can contact Secretary Perdue and demand better animal welfare standards.
Sign this petition to ban gestation crates and demand better conditions for pigs.
Make Some Noise Sweatshirt by Tiny Rescue: Climate Collection
Easy Ways to Help the Planet:
- Eat Less Meat: Download Food Monster, the largest plant-based recipe app on the App Store to help reduce your environmental footprint, save animals and get healthy. You can also buy a hard or soft copy of our favorite vegan cookbooks.
- Reduce Your Fast Fashion Footprint: Take initiative by standing up against fast fashion pollution and supporting sustainable and circular brands like Tiny Rescue that are raising awareness around important issues through recycled zero-waste clothing designed to be returned and remade over and over again.
- Support Independent Media: Being publicly-funded gives us a greater chance to continue providing you with high-quality content. Please consider supporting us by donating!
- Sign a Petition: Your voice matters! Help turn petitions into victories by signing the latest list of must-sign petitions to help people, animals, and the planet.
- Stay Informed: Keep up with the latest news and important stories involving animals, the environment, sustainable living, food, health, and human interest topics by subscribing to our newsletter!
- Do What You Can: Reduce waste, plant trees, eat local, travel responsibly, reuse stuff, say no to single-use plastics, recycle, vote smart, switch to cold water laundry, divest from fossil fuels, save water, shop wisely, donate if you can, grow your own food, volunteer, conserve energy, compost, and don’t forget about the microplastics and microbeads lurking in common household and personal care products!