Are people more likely to feel empathy for animals than other humans? According to new research, it’s not that simple.

Source: Daily Blast LIVE/Youtube

Researchers found that when people had to choose between empathizing with a human stranger or an animal (a koala bear), participants were more likely to empathize with other humans.

Then, in a second study, researchers asked participants to perform two separate tasks. In one, they would decide if they wanted to empathize with a person or not, and in the other tasks, they would choose if they wanted to empathize with an animal or not.

The second experiment found that a person was more likely to choose empathy with an animal than another human. Daryl Cameron, associate professor of psychology and senior research associate at Rock Ethics Institute at Penn State, told Futurity,

“It’s possible that if people are seeing humans and animals in competition, it might lead to them preferring to empathize with other humans,” Cameron said. “But if you don’t see that competition, and the situation is just deciding whether to empathize with an animal one day and a human the other, it seems that people don’t want to engage in human empathy but they’re a little bit more interested in animals.” The researchers concluded that the results suggest that context matters. If people are faced with both a human and an animal, it is made into an almost competition and may lead to them choosing their species and empathizing with humans.

In the first study, 193 participants were asked to choose between empathizing with a human or an animal. If they chose a fellow person, they were shown a picture of a college-aged adult and then asked to share their experience. If they chose an animal, they were presented with a picture of a koala bear and asked to do the same.

Cameron said that participants likely chose to empathize with a person because they thought it would be easier to empathize with another human.

“Participants indicated that empathizing with animals felt more challenging, and that belief of empathy being more difficult drove them to choose animal empathy less,” Cameron said. “It’s possible that people felt empathizing with a mind that’s unlike our own was more challenging than imagining the experience of another human.”

In the second experiment, they had to choose either to empathize with a person or show no empathy at all. The first task was with a person, while the other task was with an animal.

“Once humans and animals were no longer in competition, the story changed,” Cameron said. “When people had the chance to either empathize with or remain detached from a human stranger, people avoided empathy, which replicates the previous studies we’ve done. For animals, though, they didn’t show that avoidance pattern. And actually, when we decoupled humans from animals, people actually were more likely to choose to empathize with an animal than a human.”

These findings could be extremely influential in how we talk to the public about environmental issues, animal welfare, and climate change. Cameron noted that if people do empathize less with animals if animal interests are directly against humans, this could affect how people feel about environmental issues.

“If people perceive choices about empathy in a way that makes it seem like we need to choose between humans or animals with no compromise—for example, choosing between using a parcel of land or conserving it for animals—they may be more likely to side with humans,” Cameron continued. “But there may be ways in which those conversations could be tweaked to shape how people are thinking about managing their empathy.”

Related Content:

For more Animal, Earth, Life, Vegan Food, Health, and Recipe content published daily, subscribe to the One Green Planet Newsletter! Also, don’t forget to download the Food Monster App on the App Store. With over 15,000 delicious recipes, it is the largest meatless, vegan, and allergy-friendly recipe resource to help reduce your environmental footprint, save animals and get healthy!

Lastly, being publicly-funded gives us a greater chance to continue providing you with high-quality content. Please consider supporting us by donating!