Welcome Green Monsters! We're your online guide to making conscious choices that help people, animals and the planet.
Download food monster: the biggest, baddest, yummiest vegan food app!
Buy the #EatForThePlanet book



How to Make the Perfect Baked Potato


Potatoes are sometimes seen as starches that aren’t nutritious or delicious, but they can be both of those things, especially when they are baked! To ensure that your baked potatoes are the best, we have compiled five key steps in the baked potato making process. Read on, and be edified!

1. Select the best

Settling for subpar spuds is always a bad idea, especially when baked potatoes are considered. Grab large, organic taters that don’t have roots growing out of them or pimple-like shoots running all across their skin. The indents in potatoes are called eyes and the things that grow out of them are shoots. Don’t be alarmed if you have week old potatoes in your kitchen that start growing these shoots out of their eyes: it’s not alive, Dr. Frankenstein, they are just  potatoes doing their thing. But, for baking potatoes, it’s best to start with a clean product, free of shoots.

2. Give it a good wash

Grimy ground grown spuds need to be thoroughly washed. If you want your spuds to be super clean, wash them with filtered water in a big pot, scrubbing off dirt in the eyes and the occasional shoot. A shiny spud is a happy spud.

3. Wrap it in tinfoil

Get yourself some tinfoil to wrap up your spuds. You might need one or two sheets of tinfoil per potato depending on the size of them. Before wrapping said spud, take a pitchfork and stab it silly. No, I’m joking, take a normal fork and puncture holes in it. This will allow for the heat to better penetrate the potato. To wrap your spud, start with the corner of the sheet and roll the spud up like you’re swaddling a baby up in a blanket. Swaddle that spud! Make sure it’s fully covered in its tin blanket.

4. Start up the oven

For large or medium sized potatoes, it may take an hour or so at 400 degrees F to cook them through. You can check them after 45 minutes have elapsed with a fork. Simply stab the spud with the utensil and see if it goes all the way through similar to the aforementioned step about stabbing. If the fork does not go all the way through the potatoes or if they’re still hard, they are not done yet, so let them bake for another 15-20 minutes.

5. Add on some toppings

Salt and Pepper. Hummus. Broccoli. Spinach. Refried Beans. Salsa. Onions. You can put a ton of stuff on baked potatoes, and it all tastes delicious. Or, you can eat it plain; no one will judge you. So, when your baked potatoes are done, take them out of the oven with an oven mitt and unwrap them, leaving them on the tinfoil as a wimpy plate. Slice the tater down the middle, and put whatever suits you on it. You could even cut the potato up into little cubes and put them in a stirfry or in some soup. As Samwise Gamgee says, ” po-ta-toes, boil ’em, mash ’em, stick ’em in a stew.”

Get a bag of potatoes, and don’t be scared to bake them. They are great vessels that can hold numerous toppings, and they are so simple to prepare. Make your next meal a baked potato!

Image source: Whitney / Flickr

Want to read more posts like this? Sign up for our newsletter below!​

Browse through some recent posts below:

Blogger Spotlight: Caroline Doucet of Unsweetened Caroline!

Brownie Cookie Dough Ice Cream Bars

#InstaInspo: Nachos, Biscoff Doughnuts and Other Delicious Vegan Meals We Saw On Instagram This Week!

From Pumpkin Oat Pancakes to Zucchini Banana Muffins: 10 Vegan Recipes That Went Viral Last Week

Chickpea-nut Butter Ice Cream Cake

Amazon Launches All-Vegan Online Baking Store after ‘Great British Bake off Episode’

Disclosure: One Green Planet accepts advertising, sponsorship, affiliate links and other forms of compensation, which may or may not influence the advertising content, topics or articles written on this site. Click here for more information.

5 comments on “How to Make the Perfect Baked Potato”

Click to add comment
Hayes Stephanie
4 Years Ago

@ Tia.. right!! Insert sarcasm. . You are a gullible person if you believe that!!

Ocram FunLand
4 Years Ago

Joey N Marco

Ralean Nelson Staub
4 Years Ago

I've always used foil because that's what my mom did...but based on the post above, I'll try without!

Cindy Cynthia
4 Years Ago

Tin foil is the worst thing for a great potato. It steams it and makes a soggy skin. 1. Pre heat oven to 450 (you can put them in a cold oven too) 2. Chose a potato that is free of harvesting cuts or green skin. Russets are great for baking. 3. Thoroughly scrub and remove eyes and dents/ dark spots. 4. If you are not concerned about presentation but are pushed for time push a metal skewer through lengthwise. If you care about the appearance (don't want a dark hole running through the cooked product when the skewer is removed) omit this cooking time reducing step. 5. Throw it in the oven right onto the oven rack. No plate or pan or tinfoil. No oil. 6. They are done in approximately 15 to 20 mins. depending on size of potato and when you can easily push the tines of a fork half way in or to the centre of the potato.

Tia Haenni
4 Years Ago

Haven't you heard? Foil + potato = Botulism. http://www.bccdc.ca/NR/rdonlyres/B2100B09-1587-4B58-8300-251243965BBC/0/Baked_Potatos_and_Foodborne_Botulism.pdf


Subscribe to our Newsletter

Follow us on

Do Not Show This Again


Submit to OneGreenPlanet

Terms & Conditions ×