Welcome Green Monsters! We're your online guide to making conscious choices that help people, animals and the planet.
Download food monster: the biggest, baddest, yummiest vegan food app!
Buy the #EatForThePlanet book



There has been yet another carriage horse accident in New York City. On June 9th, a Belgian draft named Pumpkin was waiting at the hack line at Central Park South when something spooked him and he bolted, charging into the park, dragging his driverless carriage – coming at people. A tourist jumped into the carriage trying to control him. His driver was on the sidewalk and obviously not paying attention – something we often see.

Mets outfielder Matt den Dekker, who was in the area, tweeted ”Almost got ran over by a horse carriage running wild through the city.” What would have happened if he had been trampled and injured or worse? Would it have been a game changer?

NYC continues to dodge the bullet but it is only a matter of time before someone is seriously injured or killed.

Campaign Promise

Mayor deBlasio promised to ban the inhumane and unsafe horse-drawn carriage trade his first week in office and many people voted for him based on that promise. They also voted for him because of his progressive agenda. He quickly learned that this was a very complicated issue and a ban could not happen in a short time frame. He has said it will happen by the end of the year. And we believe him. But our patience is running thin.

When Will Enough be Enough? Another Carriage Horse Accident in NYC


Bill deBlasio is the first mayor who gets it, who has expressed compassion for these horses and a real understanding of the safety issue. He is a true advocate who has had a lot thrown at him by the right wing press – but he continues to be resolute and steadfast on his promise.

That’s what a true leader does. However, we want to impress upon the Mayor that he needs to take this more seriously and to ultimately accept the responsibility for these accidents because they are happening on his watch.

When Will Enough be Enough? Another Carriage Horse Accident in NYCImage courtesy of Elizabeth Forel

Because action was not taken early, the other side’s untruthful rhetoric now defines the issue – at least to the gullible who believe everything they read and hear. In the present onslaught of media bias against the pending carriage horse ban, which started in September after deBlasio won the Democratic mayoral primary, the rationale for a ban has been ignored. We’ve not been given equal time in the media and when we’re given any time at all; our comments are often manipulated in favor of the drivers.

The NY Daily News has been the worst offender by far, not even pretending to be objective. They even went so far as to set up a petition against the ban, handing out stickers on Central Park South telling people that the Mayor plans to send the horses to slaughter to be made into dog food. They have seemingly made this a crusade against Mayor deBlasio’s progressive agenda, using the horse-drawn carriage issue as a metaphor. To responsible journalists, it should beg the question of what exactly is going on – what has prompted this blitzkrieg. But they have been quiet on this subject.

Bogus Poll

So when Quinnipiac does a poll in this kind of biased environment, it should not be taken seriously. Months and months of propaganda and brain washing have been fed to the public – the very people who participate in the poll. Prior to this time, every poll taken showed between 75 and 80% of respondents in favor of a ban.

“It’s the Horses, Stupid”

What the media has lost sight of in their quest to bring down Mayor deBlasio, is that the very nature of the horse makes this majestic animal unsuitable to work on the crowded streets of NYC. Although gentle by nature, at 1,500 to 2,000 pounds, they can become uncontrollable, unwitting weapons when spooked. As prey animals, their nature is to respond to upsetting stimuli in a flight or fight manner – just as Pumpkin did. Horses are predictably unpredictable and there is no such thing as a “bomb proof” horse. (“It’s the economy, stupid” – was a campaign phrase coined by James Carville for Bill Clinton’s 1992 presidential campaign. It means, it was indeed the economy – just as – this issue is about the horses and their nature.)

When Will Enough be Enough? Another Carriage Horse Accident in NYC


A NYC carriage horse begins his or her day by getting “suited up” with the heavy equipment required to pull a carriage. As prey animals, a horse’s eyes are located on the side of their head to allow them to see who is coming from behind. To work the streets of NYC, a horse must wear blinders to block his peripheral vision. Often, the horse has a check rein to prevent him from lowering his head. The horse is confined between the shafts of his carriage with very little freedom of movement and can legally work up to nine hours a day, seven days a week. Much of the time he is stuck on the hack line, tied to his carriage and bored – behavior that is often manifested by repetitive stomping.

The opposition says they are “work horses” –but I beg to differ. They are entertainment horses in a frivolous, and out dated business.

When Will Enough be Enough? Another Carriage Horse Accident in NYCImage courtesy of Elizabeth Forel

Think of how you would feel if you were confined like this for hours at a time, with no freedom to even scratch an itch; that in order to perform your job, your vision would be restricted and, in some cases you’re given tranquilizers to become calm enough to work on the street.

Unfamiliar sudden movements or loud noises will often trigger an innate anxiety in a horse, which may lead to panic and fear. Generally in the city, as what just happened with Pumpkin, a horse will bolt into traffic, not caring where is he going or who is in his way. He wants desperately to distance himself from the source of danger. The horse is terrified for his life.

When Will Enough be Enough? Another Carriage Horse Accident in NYCImage courtesy of Elizabeth Forel

This is the main reason why City legislators must act responsibly and shut down this business. NYC has dodged the human death bullet many times with spooking accidents. It is only a matter of time before it happens here.

Recent Accidents

Prior to yesterday’s accident, the last reported spooking accident that occurred on NYC streets happened on April 23rd. In a recent period of less than two weeks, there were six spooking accidents around the country that were reported in the media. This is addressed in the Horse Sense newsletter.

Spooking = Death

In 2010, in Salzburg, Austria, a French tourist was knocked down and trampled by a runaway carriage horse who spooked and bolted. She died from her injuries. In 2007, there were two incidents each involving 5-year old girls and carriage horses that ended badly. In Tucson, little Brielle was sitting on a horse in a parade when several carriage horses behind her spooked. She was knocked from her horse and trampled to death. Later that year in St. Petersburg, Russia, another young girl fell from a carriage and was killed when the horse spooked and bolted.

It is past time for this, unsafe and cruel trade to be shut down and the horses sent to sanctuaries to live out their lives with dignity.

We implore Mayor deBlasio to take action now to begin this process.

Lead image source: Courtesy of Elizabeth Forel

Want to read more posts like this? Sign up for our newsletter below!​

Browse through some recent posts below:

Prince Harry and Meghan Markle Raise Awareness for Plastic Pollution During Australian Beach Cleanup!

This Supermarket Chain Is Offering Discounts on Popular Plant-Based Brands Thanks to Brilliant New Campaign

YES! Colleges, Hospitals, and Workplaces Are Getting Vegan Just Egg Sandwiches Thanks to Aramark

Awesome New Website Launches to Help Consumers Discover the Animal and Environmental Impact of Food Choices

Disclosure: One Green Planet accepts advertising, sponsorship, affiliate links and other forms of compensation, which may or may not influence the advertising content, topics or articles written on this site. Click here for more information.

0 comments on “When Will Enough Be Enough? Another Carriage Horse Accident in NYC”

Click to add comment
4 Years Ago

Thank you for writing and to Green Planet thank you for publishing this scathing article which reveals the truth that is being kept from the public by right-wing media and supporters of an industry that thrives only on lies and the good will of an ignorant and naive public. Those with the bully pulpit, those with money and power are riding high these days, as they manipulate the truth, deceive and sway people away from compassion and concern for the most needy and from the voiceless victims who are exploited by an industry without a soul. We see the results lawmakers and other elected officials refuse to take on big moneyed interests and do the right thing. Let\'s hope that Mayor deBlasio will keep his promise to make New York a more humane city, one that we can all be proud of.

Diana Beall
4 Years Ago

That a very good question. With the New York Daily News strongly supporting horse drawn carriages and lies about the Mayor wanting to slaughter the horses for dog food, I guess it all depends on what people want to believe. But, there\'s no denying the spooked runaway horses in New York City. It\'s amazing that people do not understand the danger when these large horses are in the middle of automobiles and pedestrians. The lack of compassion and concern when looking at a horse down or dead in the streets is shocking. There\'s no excuse and logical reasoning to support horses on the streets of a large city, like New York. The conditions these poor horses endure are inhumane and I\'m shocked that it has openly continued this long across the world. People need to speak up, rather be silence, against animal abuse and cruelty in New York.

Tyrone Jones
4 Years Ago

Frankly, this polluted, privatized, overcrowded city is much less than ideal for HUMAN habitation and transportation, let alone that of horses. If not for our economic obligations, I imagine many of us, along with the horses, would prefer to steer clear of the carcinogenic fumes, cramped quarters, deafening, obnoxious car horns, litter and feces-smeared concrete jungle.

Unfortunately, as long as capitalism is king in this anthropocentric world, people will be more than willing to sacrifice their own health and well-being as well as the health of other beings to \'get ahead\'. The horses are merely a sentinel indicating the risks of our own exposure, both physical and psychological. From the banker\'s business to the taxi driver\'s carriage, perhaps we too could all free ourselves from our bridles for but a moment to experience a sliver of pseudo-freedom.

As money gets tighter than the time and space we live in, we\'re no longer free to roam. This is the culture we have chosen. Aren\'t you appalled? Reduce the preposterous and inefficient vehicular traffic! Free the horses! Save the humans! Damn the queen! ...or it will only get more crowded, more dangerous and less humane for us all while chasing and competing for the almighty dollar!


Subscribe to our Newsletter

Follow us on

Do Not Show This Again


Submit to OneGreenPlanet

Terms & Conditions ×