Welcome Green Monsters! We're your online guide to making conscious choices that help people, animals and the planet.
Download food monster: the biggest, baddest, yummiest vegan food app!
Buy the #EatForThePlanet book



The domestication of animals (and plants) was born out of somewhat of a necessity for early hunter-gatherers. The process of domestication modifies a species genetically through selective breeding and ultimately allows humans to have control over an animal’s behavior.

For years, we have successfully kept dozens of species of wild animals alive in captive settings, although the debate over whether or not they’re thriving is one for another day. The process of simply keeping wild animals in captivity does not mean the species as a whole has been domesticated, nor does it mean that a specific individual is domesticated. They’re merely “tamed” and this is usually done by way of abuse, fear, or starvation.

Biologist, author, and University of California Los Angeles professor Jared Diamond references the elephant in captivity which has been captured from the wild for years and trained using a number of techniques, most of which utilize bull hooks electric prods and chains. The elephant, in this case, has been tamed, not domesticated.

According to Diamond, there are six restrictions wild animals need to pass in order for domestication to be attainable. Without even just one of these traits, the likelihood that domestication can occur lessens.

The restrictions Diamond believes stop animals from being domesticated are: diet, growth rate, disposition, reluctance to breed in captivity, social hierarchies, and their tendency to panic or flee.

Now, consider the horse that has been domesticated for at least 5,000 years. And now consider its close relative, the zebra. Despite numerous attempts, we’ve never been able to domesticate the zebra. The process of domestication is incredibly difficult, in fact, of 148 large mammalian species, only 14 of them are domesticated. Yet, many exotic animal facilities like to claim they’ve domesticated their animals, and as such, the animals love being in their care. Understanding the difference between domestication and “taming” is the key to discerning whether or not we can justify holding wild animals in captivity as pets or as zoo and circus animals.

Domestication in Practice

For many species, the process of domestication has been a slow and tedious one, but not always. In the 1950s, Russia scientist Dmitri Belyaev set up a long-term experiment to study the domestication of silver foxes. In the past 50 years he has managed to selectively breed silver foxes for tameness and against aggression. The results of his experiment show a number of behavioral, morphological. and physiological changes. In short, the animals at his facility have begun to undergo a number of the changes hypothesized by Charles Darwin to occur through domestication.

While it may certainly be possible to accelerate the domestication process for viable candidates, this isn’t true for all species. Foxes, after all, are nothing like lions, tigers, and bears. When we look at diet, growth rate, disposition, reluctance to breed in captivity, social hierarchies, and their tendency to panic or flee, they are somewhat close to that of a dog. However, for larger exotic animals, the disparities between the wild animals and domesticated cats or dogs are massively vast.

The Myth of the Domestic Exotic Pet

Although many wild animals cannot be domesticated without hundreds of years of selective breeding, that doesn’t stop exotic pet enthusiasts from fighting to keep them as pets. Of all the arguments we hear from exotic pet enthusiasts (and trust us, we’ve heard them all), one of the most common is the hypocrisy in owning dogs or cats and condemning those who wish to own wild animals.

For starters, dogs and cats were domesticated thousands of years ago, and while none of us personally contributed to their domestication, we’re certainly at least partially culpable for just how extensive the homeless pet epidemic is – more than 70 million homeless animals exist in the United States. It is our responsibility to ensure those animals are given a safe haven. Although domesticated animals may very well retain some of their wild instincts, the ramifications of simply letting them all run free would be devastating.

On the flip side, the consequences of taking free animals out of their natural habitat (especially animals like tigers and lions that are endangered) and forcing them to live in a cage in our backyards as pets is equally devastating. There are many biological and evolutionary differences between our domestic cats and dogs and wild tigers, lions, monkeys, and reptiles. We need to respect the fact that just because humans can hand-rear lion cubs does not mean that they will lose their heightened adrenal glands that drive them to hunt, or that their perfectly evolved teeth and claws will cease to be a threat.

Putting the Myth to Rest

There is an indisputable difference between owning a dog or cat and confining a lion or tiger to a captive life. All wild animals should be able to live, well, in the wild. Thousands of years ago wild animals were domesticated out of necessity, and despite any failed attempts by exotic pet owners to prove otherwise, domesticating wild animals at this junction is nothing more than self-gratification. Our energy and our focus should be on the conservation and survival of a species—particularly of endangered species—not on attempts to domesticate those that cannot be.

Image source: Tombako the Jaguar/Flickr

Want to read more posts like this? Sign up for our newsletter below!​

Browse through some recent posts below:

Report Finds If We Lose Forest Elephants, We’ll Be Making the Planet Far Less Inhabitable for People

5 Ways Factory Farming Is Killing the Environment

5 Ways Factory Farming is Killing the Environment

Why Eating Meat Is so Much More Than an Animal Rights Issue

Reasons Why Eating Meat is More Than an Animal Rights Issue

10 Reasons Why Sloth Bears Are The Cutest

Disclosure: One Green Planet accepts advertising, sponsorship, affiliate links and other forms of compensation, which may or may not influence the advertising content, topics or articles written on this site. Click here for more information.

12 comments on “The Myth of Domestication: Why Exotic Animals Can Never Really be ‘Pets’”

Click to add comment
6 Months Ago

Having a bear as a pet is not without it\'s danger. While 80% of the time all is well; the other 20% of the problematics make me thing we have a long way to go for domesticated brown bears. This will be my last one.

1 Years Ago

Strange the only evidence given seems to show that domestication is entirely possible and has been dome many times.
No mention is made of advanced methods like genetics engineering which could greatly speed up the process or even create entirely new species.
This article is not too convincing.

Miss Cellany
1 Years Ago

This article fails to mention that dogs and cats were NOT domesticated by humans. They domesticated themselves, or more accurately, evolution domesticated them. Red foxes (silver foxes are a variant of red fox) have also taken the first few steps towards domestication on their own (moving into towns and cities and scavenging from our rubbish) - it would probably be easy to domesticate red foxes from city fox stock if anyone was so inclined (with strict selective breeding), the same goes for city coyotes.

Ursula Hess
2 Years Ago

Why should they be "pets"? Gosh, there are enough domestic animals arount.

Jessica Weidman
2 Years Ago

It's upsetting but it's better to think about these animals being happy in their natural habitats with their own kind.

Jonathan Michael Knox
2 Years Ago

That has got to be about the prettiest tiger I've ever saw! How the hell could someone ever want to make something like him submissive? Isn't he a better friend if he feels valued?

Christine Hinton
2 Years Ago

Just stupid they are wild animals respect

Joe Exotic
3 Years Ago

People who write this stuff knows nothing about exotic animals

joe exotic
28 May 2015

....you must be so well versed in domesticating wild animals

to: joe exotic
28 May 2015

... you must be so well versed in domesticating wild animals

Kane Spence
3 Years Ago

This whole article is written by someone who doesn\'t really know anything about animals or how domestication works.

27 May 2015

Could you please explain where you think the article is wrong? This is a genuine question, as I failed to see anything to really disagree with. I\'m wondering which part you don\'t agree with.

27 May 2015

Spoken like someone who must be trying to own or sell a wild animal.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Follow us on

Do Not Show This Again


Submit to OneGreenPlanet

Terms & Conditions ×